Best 9mm service style pistol?

D

DubC-Hicks

New member
What "service" style pistols do you guys like? I'm in college for law enforcement right now, and while I have some time till firearms training, I want to get ahead of the game. I'm looking for a nice full size 9mm, preferably SA/DA, but striker fired is ok. I'm wanting low recoil, accurate, and a nice trigger, so I can hopefully master all of the fundamentals. I've had a Glock 31 for a while now, but am wanting something different and cheaper to shoot.

So far I am liking the M9/92fs, Sig p226, and FNX-9 the most. What other suggestions would you guys have for me?
 
S

sigarms228

New member
IMHO the SIG P226 would be an outstanding choice if it works well for you. As always, if at all possible, try out what you are considering first. Just holding in the hand at the gun store and maybe dry firing does not tell that much compared to actually shooting to see the results and feel the recoil, etc.

The Beretta is a great choice also but I don't know much about the FN-X. I would add that the HK P30L is something to definitely check out and it comes in a variety of trigger configurations including DA/SA and LEM. The P30L DA/SA can also be had with or without an external frame mounted safety.

Good luck!!

This is my new P30L. I also have a couple SIG P226s.

http://pistol-training.com/archives/2668 -- P30 endurance test

 
Last edited:
S

smee78

New member
It depends on what you want it for, if for work then you will have an approved list to work from. If for fun then I would look at the S&W 5906 if you want an all SS gun that is DA/SA, if striker fire then I like my Glock 19.
 
F

Fireman179

New member
I had a FN FNP and I traded it on a Beretta M9. The M9 feels way better in my hand and I like the trigger better. The only reason I chose the M9 over the 92fs is I like the dot and post sight better.
 
W

Webleymkv

New member
If you really want to "get ahead of the game" as you say, then it seems to me that the wisest option would be a gun most similar to what you'll be training with and/or issued once you graduate. Glocks and Sigs seem to be the most popular among LE agencies so that's probably a good place to start looking.
 
S

SpareMag

New member
Walther PPQ should be considered. Great -for me - fit, great sights, widely regarded in Europe. Get the M1 model!
 
A

Aguila Blanca

Staff
My vote would go to the Browning Hi-Power or the CZ-75b, but I'm old fashioned. Of those two, the CZ-75b is probably easier to find and is currently in wider use (worldwide) than the Hi-Power, but both are excellent 9mm pistols with a long rack record of service (police and military).
 
J

jr24

New member
If you want DA/SA my preference would be for a Sig P226 (or P229) or the CZ 75.

If you really want to get a leg up for LEO you're probably going to want a Glock as that's what seems to still be the most popular, might as well get used to it.
 
D

Dragline45

New member
I'm in college for law enforcement right now, and while I have some time till firearms training, I want to get ahead of the game.
Click to expand...

If you know what PD you are planning on joining up with find out what they carry. Chances are it's either a Glock or an M&P, although many departments still carry Sig's and Beretta's.
 
B

btmj

New member
I have a Glock 17 and 19 and shoot both regularly. The G19 is my wintertime carry. I am a fan of Glock, but more important to my decision is that I have been shooting Glocks since 1990. I have more rounds though Glocks than any other pistol.

Based on my limited shooting of the SW MP, I would say it is the equal of the Glock, and perhaps even better. You can't go wrong with MP.

I recently got a FNH FNX-40. I have to say I am totally impressed by this firearm. If I were in charge of selecting a new service pistol for a police department, and I had to pick a DA/SA pistol, I would pick the FNX.

The FNS is a striker fired pistol, and thus it competes against Glock, SW, and Ruger SR.... A lot of competition there. It might have an edge, but just barely.

SIG P226 is a very fine gun, but price has to play a part in all of this, and I just don't think the high price is justified when compared to the FNH, Glock, and SW. Same with HK... Really nice gun, but not worth the price.

The SIG pro 2022 is really nice DA/SA pistol, and about the same price as a Glock or FNH. I have never shot one, but it is worth a look.

The Ruger SR series is under-rated in my opinion. I am not sure why we don't see more of them in police service, but it would be a fine choice.

The Beretta M9/92 is a great shooting pistol, and IMO one of the best looking semi-auto pistols of all time. They are getting pricey however.
 
D

DubC-Hicks

New member
I have the glock that I can get a .40 barrel for, so I'll be able to practice with that too. I'm trying to get into the Michigan State police, and they carry the P226, so that's why I'm thinking about that. The local agencies here carry an XD45, but they change almost every couple years so I'm not sure what they'll have when I get there.

I shot the M9 and P226 today. The Sig feels better in my hand, but I shot the M9 quite a bit better. I didn't get a lot of time with either though.
 
C

ClydeFrog

Moderator
Better? Cheaper?....

I don't think "better" & cheaper can be in the same sentence. :confused:

You can find decent offers on a few sources, www.jgsales.com www.gunsamerica.com www.gilbertsguns.com www.slickguns.com .

Don't forget as a sworn LE officer you qualify for "blue label" & LE discounts, ;) .

I'd look at a SIG P226R DAK(Double Action Kesselman) or P229R DAK, a HK P30 LEM(law enforcement modification), a Beretta PX4 Storm C(constant action), a Walther PPQ, a FNH FNS.
You might find a LE trade in for now to train with. SIG Sauer has CPO models(certified pre owned) that are covered by a 1 year warranty.
The Smith & Wesson M&P line is great too. I owned a 9x19mm in 2011 that did very well.
A DA only format makes more sense for duty/LE to me. It's safe, won't jab or rub against your side(with a spurless hammer) & you avoid false complaints or claims that you cocked a DA/SA hammer(acted reckless).

3 dot night sights are worth adding. Many like the XS line or the new HD series from Trijicon.
 
T

Tomac

New member
As mentioned previously, whatever's closest to what you'll be issued.
Aside from that, the SIG P2022 is a very underrated (IMHO) DA/SA pistol that was designed for a major French police contract and should cost hundreds more than it does.
Tomac
 
Last edited:
R

rodfac

New member
For accuracy, it's my P226 Mk25, 10 shots in less than an inch and a quarter from a 25 yd rested position. While I like a 1911's flatter grip panels, that Sig can sure shoot. It's equally accurate with the Sig .40 S&W slide/barrel assembly.

Considering both the ergonomics, and accuracy from combat distances: 3 to 15 yds, I'd vote for a Glock 17 or 19. I have considerable experience with both, and my wife's beside gun is a 19. Both are absolutely reliable, more so than any other pistol I've ever used. Fugly? Yes. But great fighting guns.

Best Regards, Rod
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top