Same exact thing happened to me. I started owning three bottom feeders and like others got real tired of chasing my brass all over the range. Besides, the few times I've gone to an indoor range, I found that retrieving my brass to be way too hard.
My first revolver was a Heritage Arms 32 H&R magnum. Those little rounds are really sweet and produce a satisfying amount of recoil and noise.
Second revolver was a S&W Governor. Another fun gun to shoot even though the recoil is huge.
I'm now eyeballing a Ruger 357/9mm convertible with a 6.5" barrel. Man that should be nice.
Every time I tell my wife that this gun will be the last one I'll buy, another one pops up on my radar. So far I've told her that five times.