Speed loaders

[SAWBONES]

I've used both the Safariland and HKS "speedloaders" extensively in 5-shot S&W J-frames and Ruger SP101s.

There's really no comparison.

The Safariland Comp loaders are altogether superior.

Lightweight, stable (no rattling cartridges like HKS), no knob to turn; just push then drop the empty loader, then close the cylinder.

 

[marv]

Guess I'll have to send my new Safariland 5rd loader back. Have to use pliers to turn the knob when I fill it and then it won't release the rounds into the gun. I have a couple HKS 36W loaders. One is marked 1 and the rounds are wiggly. The other is marked 2 and they are tight.
The OEM rubber grips on my M642 would not allow the use of a speedloader. Had to get a Hogue Bantam grip,

 

[Webleymkv]

While I've not seen it myself, Grant Cunningham reports that the manner in which Maxfire speed loaders are used can cause bent cranes and recommends against their use.

http://www.grantcunningham.com/blog_files/speedloader_brands.html

While I suppose this is possible, I'd think that one would have to be rather, um, vigorous when using a Maxfire to bend a crane. Nonetheless, as I mentioned earlier, I find Maxfires to be awkward enough that I won't use them for any serious purpose regardless of their risk of bent cranes.