i've had one for about, maybe 6 months. i don't care what type of alloy they're made of, well a little. but it feels plenty solid in my hand. it shoots wel, and really tames the .357 recoil and flip. at first the price was off putting, as someone else mentioned. but i thought because of the uniqueness, i really wanted one. so i did. now i really want one of those 4" white ones with the wood grips. i think they look cool, far from ugly. if you think they are ugly, good for you, but you should really shoot one and then reelvaluate. i'm actually going to go shoot mine today, just with some 38 reloads.