1911 pattern pistols: 'scallops', or no?

Cut-out 'scallops' in the frame behind the 1911 pattern pistol's trigger. Yea or Nay?

  • Having the cut-out 'scallops' is a must for me. They help my shooting

    Votes: 4 9.1%
  • The cut-out 'scallops' don't matter to me at all and don't affect my shooting

    Votes: 16 36.4%
  • I like the looks of the scallops

    Votes: 14 31.8%
  • I prefer how the pistol looks without the scallops

    Votes: 12 27.3%

  • Total voters
    44
  • Poll closed .

Chris_B

New member
The trigger's different, too, and something else but I forget what.

You mean on a Model of 1911 vs. M1911A1? Actually a bunch of things, obvious and not so obvious are different. But I'm not talking strictly about US military firearms. We could go on for pages about the changes between the Model of 1911 and the M1911A1- heat treating, finishes, shapes of hammers, grip safeties, grips, locations of markings, sights, mag releases, thumb safeties, etc

One thing I'm wondering is why so few new 1911 pattern pistols have the frame configuration (ie: no 'scallops'), and the overwhelming majority do have them. except for the short 're-issue' model Colt did a while back in which they made pistols very much like 1918 production Colts, I can think of only a couple custom pistol makers that have made the 'non-scalloped' models

It would seem to me that it is odd, given the wild popularity of the basic pistol type, that this option has not been explored

In regards to what you probably meant though, the trigger, mainspring housing (arched vs. straight), and 'flat' vs. 'scalloped' frame are the most obvious

But for this pistol type, a thing like a trigger or mainspring is a fairly simple swap. It's a little more advanced to go from a non-scalloped frame to a scalloped one ;)
 

MidwestRookie

New member
lol at that picture's captions...

well played, sir. I pictured this guy when reading it..

186659328_c058cff2cb.jpg


I've honestly never thought about it. in fact, I had to go on Ed Brown's website to see if the special forces I ordered comes with or without them. (with)

What causes such a tiny detail to affect how the gun shoots? (serious question)
 
Top