World-wide, Gun Bans Breed Defiance

A

Al Norris

Moderator Emeritus
I have always pretty much figured that if it actually came to registration, or heavens forbid, confiscation, that most in the US would roll over. It appears I may be wrong.

According to an article by J.D. Tuccille, world-wide, and even here in the US, defiance of radical gun restrictions are the natural order.

Gun Restrictions Have Always Bred Defiance, Black Markets - Reason.com

A very good article that appears to honestly say that people just won't follow unjust law.
 
D

David White

New member
Al Norris said:
I have always pretty much figured that if it actually came to registration, or heavens forbid, confiscation, that most in the US would roll over. It appears I may be wrong.
Click to expand...

Speak for yourself.
I have NO intentions of "rolling over".
I also have no qualms about who will be "playing dead" either.

(Ill give you a hint; it won't be me)
 
I

iraiam

New member
At least I know I won't be alone, I already have a great deal of contempt for our government at large, they are making it worse on almost a daily basis.
 
H

Hunterpeaks

New member
Prohibibition: Highest crime rate in USA ever.

"Effective enforcement of the alcohol ban during the Prohibition Era proved to be very difficult and led to widespread flouting of the law. The lack of a solid popular consensus for the ban resulted in the growth of vast criminal organizations, including the modern American Mafia, and various other criminal cliques. Widespread disregard of the law also generated rampant corruption among politicians and within police forces."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prohibition_in_the_United_States
 
M

MLeake

New member
My ancestors made a good bit of lucre back when alcohol was banned. (Shifty Sicilians, oh my...) Seems many of their customers were the wealthy and the politically connected, too.

Lessons:

1 - Bans don't work.

2 - Bans are for the little people.
 
T

Tom Servo

Staff
I have always pretty much figured that if it actually came to registration, or heavens forbid, confiscation, that most in the US would roll over. It appears I may be wrong.
Click to expand...
Will they rise up in armed defiance? Nope. Will they take political action? Not for the most part.

But, will all the guns get turned in? Not if the historical trend holds. Canada, Australia, and the UK are estimated to average a 20% compliance rate with their bans.

I went shooting in Victoria in 1994, and there were a lot of guns that came out when nobody was looking. Most folks admitted to owning guns off the registry. It was routinely flaunted.

My sister and her husband were in Cairo during the revolution a couple of years back, and when the police absconded, pretty much everyone in the neighborhood started digging guns out of the closet they'd "forgotten" they had.

The same holds true in places like New York and Maryland. Guns may be turned into a dirty little secret, but they'll still be there.
 
D

Dr Big Bird PhD

New member
Will they rise up in armed defiance? Nope. Will they take political action? Not for the most part.
Click to expand...
Erm.... I'm afraid this might not be entirely true.

I have nothing to argue from or with, but I just don't see it ending "peacefully"
 
H

hermannr

New member
Well, at least in Canada, they got tired enough of wasting money on something that obviously did not work, they actually elected a PM that actively campaigned on removing the long gun registration.

Too bad he hasn't mannaged to do the same with handguns.
 
P

pturner67

New member
I'm not defiant. The current government is. I have the 2nd Amendment on my side. In that, it is very clear what is and is not allowed.

"the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed"


Oxford Dictionary's definition of infringe:

1 actively break the terms of (a law, agreement, etc.):

2 act so as to limit or undermine (something); encroach on


The government has no legal right to take away or limit in this case. Therefor, any law created to limit my rights is an unconstitutional law by a defiant government.
 
S

Strafer Gott

New member
We can learn much from our neighbors to the north. Raising hell ain't it.
I just know we can make it through many more media cycles without loosing our cool. Even 911 slipped the media attention span relatively quickly.
Use the courts and money to slow this freight train down, and let the anti's wear themselves to a frazzle. We ought to know about the fleeting focus of the media by now.
 
J

johnwilliamson062

Moderator
There is a movie where a person rents a gun in Japan for 6 hours or something then returns it after using it to kill someone. I thought that had to be made up, then did some research and found that for a considerable time in post-war Japan there were in fact illegal gun rentals for carrying out crimes. Craziest criminal behavior or economic market I ever heard of, well with the exception of women's hand bags.

I have heard that support of a "revolution" in the colonies in the days before "the shot heard 'round the world" hovered around 5%. Once it was apparent armed conflict was coming and there was no avoiding it, that number grew very quickly.

Prior to the Civil War it seems there were similar although not as low numbers.

We have probably all seen figures for percentage of Muslims that are "radicalized" yet we have two wars and many more theaters of operation(most of which aren't going so well). Before we go in the numbers usually hover around the 15%, then as soon as US troops land they soar.

A small minority can force widespread conflict.

Anyone need a diplomat?
 
K

KyJim

New member
If they ever passed a ban, I would sell every single gun I own before the ban went into effect. I would expect a lot of us here to do the same thing.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top