Which one would I be more more scared of...
Depends...
Walking around during the day, the Wilson, because the first thing a 2-Tone 1911 says to me is "Custom! This guy knows his guns!"
Walking around at night, the Wilson again, because the only part of a full black Taurus I'd be able to see at night is the muzzle flash right before I hit the ground. At least the Wilson might reflect some light off the shiny areas and let me know to either fight or hit the fence.
Now, if someone drew either of those guns in my house... well... that's another story
Neither one would scare me too much. I've got a Springfield .45 with 13 230-gr JHP's under the bed, my roommate directly across the hall has a Benelli Supernova 12ga. with pistol grip loaded with 3.5" shells, roommate down the hall has an Alexander Arms AR-15 with the 6.5mm Grendel upper receiver and scope (not that a scope would much help indoors...), and the roommate downstairs has a Remington 20ga. semi-auto.
Talk about being
slightly outgunned... I feel sorry for any stranger who draws a firearm in my house