The BAR has always been the finest semi-auto sporter made, in my opinion. But they have discontinued them recently. There are still plenty on the shelves now and I would grab one. The Remington is OK, it just requires a lot of cleaning if anything like it's predecesors, which it has to be. The Benelli is probably a great gun, with their experience making semis, but they're ugly as hell. I would grab the Browning, they have a good time tested track record and are definitely the best looking of the bunch.