Magnum Wheel Man
New member
I was just reading the thread "brass flakes" & didn't want to sidetrack the OP's thread...
I've been wet tumbling now for over a year, done many 1,000's of cases, ranging from belted magnums, to the lil 25 autos I've been working on lately, I always tumble only one size of case at a time, & I've been very happy with the results...
I'm using an old RCBS Sidewinder ( really old, was my FIL's so may be 25 years old now )... it's about worn out, & I'm getting ready to replace it... ( BTW... I'm sure the Sidewinder was designed for dry media, as wet tumbling of cartridge brass was pretty much un-heard of 25 years ago )... my FIL used it with cob or walnut media... I was not impressed with the results, & switched over to wet tumbling
my question stems from the huge amount of time variance owners are saying they are tumbling... some as short as an hour & a half, & reporting clean shiny brass, some saying 4 to 4.5 hours... with my old worn out RCBS, I get best results with about 12 hours...I only have 2.5 lbs of pins, but the RCBS tumbler I think has a smaller tumbling chamber than some of the others, coupled with the fact, that because of the worn out condition, if mine gets too heavy, it won't spin... but I don't get the level of clean & shine, or my primer pockets spotless much before 12 hours...
so I'm assuming the speed ( rpm ) of the tumbler, combined with the adjatation level of the drum, & or possibly the size, effect the time... I understand there could be differences in user expectations of what is clean & shiny... but if I could cut my time down, when I buy a new tumbler that would be great... I'll probably buy the Thumler that they recommend for tumbling brass, but now we have the new Frankford Arsenal, & Thumler makes several models
was just curious what the guys are using that are getting such short tumbling times
I've been wet tumbling now for over a year, done many 1,000's of cases, ranging from belted magnums, to the lil 25 autos I've been working on lately, I always tumble only one size of case at a time, & I've been very happy with the results...
I'm using an old RCBS Sidewinder ( really old, was my FIL's so may be 25 years old now )... it's about worn out, & I'm getting ready to replace it... ( BTW... I'm sure the Sidewinder was designed for dry media, as wet tumbling of cartridge brass was pretty much un-heard of 25 years ago )... my FIL used it with cob or walnut media... I was not impressed with the results, & switched over to wet tumbling
my question stems from the huge amount of time variance owners are saying they are tumbling... some as short as an hour & a half, & reporting clean shiny brass, some saying 4 to 4.5 hours... with my old worn out RCBS, I get best results with about 12 hours...I only have 2.5 lbs of pins, but the RCBS tumbler I think has a smaller tumbling chamber than some of the others, coupled with the fact, that because of the worn out condition, if mine gets too heavy, it won't spin... but I don't get the level of clean & shine, or my primer pockets spotless much before 12 hours...
so I'm assuming the speed ( rpm ) of the tumbler, combined with the adjatation level of the drum, & or possibly the size, effect the time... I understand there could be differences in user expectations of what is clean & shiny... but if I could cut my time down, when I buy a new tumbler that would be great... I'll probably buy the Thumler that they recommend for tumbling brass, but now we have the new Frankford Arsenal, & Thumler makes several models
was just curious what the guys are using that are getting such short tumbling times
Last edited: