Jayhawkhuntclub
New member
Which would you pick? I'd have to pay at least $200 (maybe $300) more for the DW. This will be a major purchase for me as I'm not a rich man. Thanks for your opinions.
SW1911 vs Dan Wesson Pointman 7 or CBOB?
- Thread starter Jayhawkhuntclub
- Start date
Playboypenguin
Moderator
Of those three, the Classic bobtail. I just bought one and I cannot seem to put it down. It is amazing. I cannot wait to get to the range with it this weekend and really try it out.
I guess it would all come down to what you are wanting it for though. Are you wanting just a basic CCW or are you wanting a precision range tool?
I guess it would all come down to what you are wanting it for though. Are you wanting just a basic CCW or are you wanting a precision range tool?
Two things. In general, you get what you pay for. The DWs being more expensive will most likely be a bit better. Having a CBOB, I'll say they are excellent.
Second item: S&W has a history of inconsistency in their quality. I have two S&Ws that are excellent. I also sold two other S&Ws that were far less. My CBOB is all anyone could even think about in excellent quality.
Second item: S&W has a history of inconsistency in their quality. I have two S&Ws that are excellent. I also sold two other S&Ws that were far less. My CBOB is all anyone could even think about in excellent quality.
Jayhawkhuntclub
New member
A little of both really. But I doubt I'll ever carry it much on my person (maybe in my vehicle though). I'd love to shoot some nice groups at the range. I'm not sure how I'd make out with a 4.25" barrel though.
XD45Compact
New member
If purchasing this 1911 for carry, the CBOB, no doubt. The bobbed frame will assist in concealment as will the commander-sized barrel.
If using it for target and/or competition...with no doubt the PM7. Much higher quality parts within the DW with the only MIM part, I believe....being the hammer. You can argue MIM vs. Non-MIM till the cows come home...but if given the choice, I'd take non any day...and that's coming from someone with a Kimber that I LOVE which has its share of MIM parts (and no, none of the MIM parts have malfunctioned in any way).
I just think that the DW is a higher quality pistol.
If using it for target and/or competition...with no doubt the PM7. Much higher quality parts within the DW with the only MIM part, I believe....being the hammer. You can argue MIM vs. Non-MIM till the cows come home...but if given the choice, I'd take non any day...and that's coming from someone with a Kimber that I LOVE which has its share of MIM parts (and no, none of the MIM parts have malfunctioned in any way).
I just think that the DW is a higher quality pistol.
Now that you've explained your intentions more fully, I'd say the CBOB. Same high-quality parts. Concealable, if you want it to be (includes night sights). Long enough barrel for reasonable range practice. All steel for durability. And, arguably the most beautiful pistol for the money. What's not to like?
Playboypenguin
Moderator
I agree, now that you have clarified your needs the Bobtail is even more favored.
Fusileer72
New member
Have you gone to the site and seen the DW Patriot video? That should help you make up your mind. They put about six through the same hole and one slight flyer that still cuts the main hole with the edge of the bullet. Check this out.
http://danwesson.sectordevelopment.com/products/catalog/1/5
http://danwesson.sectordevelopment.com/products/catalog/1/5
Sorry to thread hijack, but as a pure carry piece is the recommendation still the same between the 1911PD Scandium Commander and DW CBOB?
I had the chance to handle a CBOB today and it was ridiculously nice. However I could feel the extra weight on it vs. the scandium-framed S&W. Having never carried before I'm not sure how much stock to put into the extra heft.
I will be purchasing one of these as my primary carry piece in the next month or so. They are about the same price at buds.
I had the chance to handle a CBOB today and it was ridiculously nice. However I could feel the extra weight on it vs. the scandium-framed S&W. Having never carried before I'm not sure how much stock to put into the extra heft.
I will be purchasing one of these as my primary carry piece in the next month or so. They are about the same price at buds.
Now is a really good time to order a DW Pointman or CBOB. Larry Correia is running a CZ group buy right now. Best prices anywhere.
Playboypenguin
Moderator
I have never noticed that the S&W 1911's were lighter. Are you sure you are comparing stainless to stainless or are you comparing an alloy frame Smith to the all stainless steel Dan Wesson?
Playboypenguin
Moderator
That would make the decision for me right there...no aluminum or scandium frames for me. I prefer all steel. he couple of ounces you save are not worth it to me. I do not even really notice the difference in a good holster and the alloys are practically impossible to fix if damaged. 