Speedloaders - HKS vs Safariland Comp 2

[Evil Dog]

When out shooting Practical Pistol with my favorite 1952 vintage K-38 6", I have 4 of the HKS speedloaders on my belt. Have considered going to the Safariland Comp 2 but have no experience with them. Which do you consider easier to use and more secure as far as NOT accidently dumping the rounds on the ground?

 

[Charles S]

Which do you consider easier to use....

Safariland Comp 2

more secure as far as NOT accidently dumping the rounds on the ground?

the HKS speed loader

For me there is no perfect answer. When I shot competing I preferred the Safarilands. Now, for general use, I almost exclusively use HKS.

HKS will last forever, Safarilands wear out. It all depends on what you are looking for, if you are looking for the absolutly fastest use Safariland. If you want durability and security go with HKS.