Beyond_Visual_Range
New member
Finally my choices are down to Sig P226 and Walther P99, but I have to pick one for my "general purpose" 9mm. In other words, this will be the primary shooter when I go to range, and one that I can count on defending the house with.
I like Sig due to it's proven reliability and all steel construction. It fits comfortably in my hand, and the ones I've handled had great trigger pull and action. It has readily available and reasonably priced hi cap mags. But I've read about occasional SIG slide cracking problems. Also the NIB price is pretty high, I just can't afford one brand new. I'm currently considering VG+ police trade in with night sights for $400 or so, it's a pretty tempting price. Are there problems with police trade ins? I don't care about finish wear, but I dont' know how good the barrel is.
I also like Walther P99, it's just very ergonomic in my palm (even better than SIG). But it has a lot of polymer which as a conservative I'm not sure how well I trust its durability. The trigger doesn't feel as good as SIG but still great. The hi cap mags are very expensive, but the pistol itself can be had for under $480 NIB.
So based on the information I proved, what do you think would suit me better? Thanks for any insights, especially about police trade in's.
I like Sig due to it's proven reliability and all steel construction. It fits comfortably in my hand, and the ones I've handled had great trigger pull and action. It has readily available and reasonably priced hi cap mags. But I've read about occasional SIG slide cracking problems. Also the NIB price is pretty high, I just can't afford one brand new. I'm currently considering VG+ police trade in with night sights for $400 or so, it's a pretty tempting price. Are there problems with police trade ins? I don't care about finish wear, but I dont' know how good the barrel is.
I also like Walther P99, it's just very ergonomic in my palm (even better than SIG). But it has a lot of polymer which as a conservative I'm not sure how well I trust its durability. The trigger doesn't feel as good as SIG but still great. The hi cap mags are very expensive, but the pistol itself can be had for under $480 NIB.
So based on the information I proved, what do you think would suit me better? Thanks for any insights, especially about police trade in's.