Really DUMB....THEORETICAL.... musing.

Lavan

New member
For some reason I was wasting brain energy and wondering what would happen if a LIVE 45 ACP was loaded into, oh, say a 50 cal. muzzle loading rifle.
Would the pressure detonate the primer in the ACP?
Would it just be an odd projectile?

What?

:confused: :eek:

Tolja it was a DUMB musing. :)
 

ballardw

New member
In lieu of the intended projectile or addition to? Before/after an actual .50 ball? Details matter.

I might suggest trying it with a round with no powder in lieu of a .50 ball. See if the primer ignites.
Looking for a speed-loading method for a .50?
 

Hawg

New member
I kinda doubt it would ignite it but if it did I doubt there would be any damage without chamber pressure.
 

Pahoo

New member
Say a little prayer !!!

Tolja it was a DUMB musing.
The only positive input, I can give on this thread, is to make sure you say a little prayer before you pulling the trigger. ... :rolleyes:

As a youth, I did many questionable things and although I still have all my fingers. I have my share of scars. !!!! :)

Be Safe !!!
 

FrankenMauser

New member
Depends how you want to load it.

attachment.php


attachment.php


attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20200126_d.jpg
    IMG_20200126_d.jpg
    107.9 KB · Views: 175
  • IMG_20200126_a.jpg
    IMG_20200126_a.jpg
    112.9 KB · Views: 172
  • IMG_20200126_c.jpg
    IMG_20200126_c.jpg
    85.1 KB · Views: 172

FrankenMauser

New member
attachment.php



This was a .45 Auto case wedged over a .54 cal round ball, 16" down the barrel from a 325 gr .54 conical. Fired with a dangerous over-charge.
Went through six 1.5" pine boards and lodged in a stump. :eek:

attachment.php


attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20200126_b.jpg
    IMG_20200126_b.jpg
    156.4 KB · Views: 172
  • IMG_20230718_101722192.jpg
    IMG_20230718_101722192.jpg
    124.1 KB · Views: 174
  • IMG_20230718_101716370.jpg
    IMG_20230718_101716370.jpg
    121.3 KB · Views: 177

Pahoo

New member
Murphy's-Law !!!

During our "Teaching-the Instructor's" Classes on M/L's, we have a section that I call "Murphy's-Law, on what unexpected situations, you might encounter. Basically, an example is; what may be stuck or inserted into an M/L bore and the list keeps growing. I guess the most uncommon item I've found, is Bubble-Gum and modeling clay. Also found a AA flashlight battery and of course it was rotted open. :(

Be Safe !!!
 

cslinger

New member
I guess the most uncommon item I've found, is Bubble-Gum and modeling clay. Also found a AA flashlight battery and of course it was rotted open.

Ok I can KINDA (not really but for sake of argument) wrap my head around the bubble gum or clay thing as maybe sort of a "Patch substitute???" kind of thing or maybe the thought was to try and remove a stuck ball and use something sticky???? but a AA battery????????? I got nothing.
 

bedbugbilly

New member
Since this is "Pretend" time . . . .

!st lesson - black powder explodes - smokeless powder burns.

Pistol cartridges utilize powders that are at or near the top of the burn rate chart (where the "faster powders" reside / / / /

You use the word "ignite" . . . . the pistol cartridge is self contained with the slug taper crimped into the case mouth.

So let's assume you load the cartridge in the barrel, base down with the primer facing down . . . .

Now I digress for a moment . . . as a former firefighter. we encountered ammunition "popping off" numerous times while fighting a structure fire - the ammunition is in an unconfined space, so when super heated, it will ignite the smokless powder to the point of igniting it, but because the cartridges are not confined in a barrel, when the pressure builds up enough that the slug will "pop" from the casing and danger is USUALLY minimal. Containers of smokeless powder in plastic containers will usually flare up and burn when it gets hot enough fo the container to melt. Black Powder IS A WHOLE DIFFERENT STORY. And some canned food stored in cupboards - when super heated, will explode as well. I saw that several times and actually got hit in my airlock by a kitchen cabinet door that was blown off.

So now roll the dice . . .

You fore the rifle and MAYBE the cartridge will clear the barrel before the explosion of the BP and the hot gasses have the chance to super heat it, causing it to cook off . . .

OE

The initial explosion COULD force the primer to compress it enough to strike the primer anvil, setting the cartridge off - you would then have the primer pressure plus the powder charge pressure - in the confines of the bore . . . now granted, the cartridge would be traveling down the bore - BUT - do we know if it will CLEAR the bored before the cartridge fires??? Maybe Yes . . . Maybe no . . . HOW LUCKY DO YOU FEEL TODAY?

IF the cartridge blows in the barrel, there very likely may be enough pressure ti ring the barrel, bulge the barrel or even fracture the barrel, my guess about half was or towards the muzzle . . . in which case you might earn the nickname "Stubby" for the rest of your life.

Now we're just "pretending" here . . . . DO NOT TRY THIS AT HOME.

Like Mother's always say . . . "Don;t put anything smaller than your elbow in your ear." And like my Dad always said . . . "You can't fix stupid." That's why my wife has told me for 51 years to not let my thoughts wander abd think about things that could get me in trouble!" :)
 
Top