With some brand new Win. .45-70 cases I found the same trouble when sizing. This time I did a few on purpose to confirm what happened last time -- it did: when I just (lightly) rolled the case over the pad with the recommended amount of lube applied, the sizing die mashed four or five diamond-shaped dents about a third of the way down from the mouth. When I used my fingers and basically massaged a sheen onto a case, it sized with no problem. I even tried a couple with no lube and they came out fine. This is an RCBS Cowboy die and is not carbide. Only lost three cases, as the hand-massaged (oh, boy ) cases didn't get a single ding. What gives? Are .45-70 cases known to be a might delicate? By the way, why aren't there carbide sizers available for every caliber? I'd buy 'em to avoid the heartache (not to mention the degradation).