Need some advice on a stuck nipple

U

UtahHunting

New member
I recently picked up an 1851 Griswold manufactured 1963. I doubt the nipples have ever been removed. I don't think the gun has been fired. I use a homemade nipple wrench I made with a socket. I was only able to remove 1 of the 6 nipples. I have tried PB Blaster (granted I only let it soak about 10 minutes) but they will not budge.

What can you all recommend in the way of a homemade solvent to loosen them? Or should I just shoot the hell out of it and not worry?
 
R

Rigmarol

New member
I have great luck using Kroil as a penetration oil.

If the gun works fine, shoot it.

If the nipples are seized, be prepared to possibly ruin them getting them off, have spares on hand unless you don't mind waiting to replace them.

I have destroyed two dedicated nipple wrenches in the past, I'd like to see your home made wrench if possible.

Good luck.
 
B

bedbugbilly

New member
I've had luck in the past by applying a little heat as well - and then dousing with penetrating oil, brake fluid, etc. Sometimes they can be stubborn little devils and like many others, I've also have broken some nipple wrenches in the process. Hopefully you can get 'em broken free with out damaging them. I once had a stubborn one on an original 1861 Springfield that I ended up having to bore and use a "take me out" on. The biggest thing is to not get frustrated and cause damage to the internal threads - nipples are cheap compared to having to do a lot of work to restore nipple pockets on cylinders. Plus, don't be in a rush in spite of your desire to get it taken care of so you can shoot it. Let it spend some time soaking. Good luck!
 
D

deerslayer303

New member
I second the Kroil Penetrating oil, but that stuff is hard to find at a local retailer, PB Blaster is good stuff too. Try standing the cylinder up (nipple side down) and spray PB Blaster in the chambers and let it sit and soak the threads that way.
 
B

BirchOrr

New member
FWIW

In independent studies, Kano-Kroil is the best penetrating oil available. In this same test, the only concoction that worked even better was a 50/50 mixture of acetone and automatic trans fluid.

Good luck!

Birch
 
T

TomADC

New member
Yep shop brew 50/50 mix auto trans fluid & acetone.
Something else I like is Oil of Wintergreen plus a good fitting wrench.
 
U

UtahHunting

New member
I have great luck using Kroil as a penetration oil.

If the gun works fine, shoot it.

If the nipples are seized, be prepared to possibly ruin them getting them off, have spares on hand unless you don't mind waiting to replace them.

I have destroyed two dedicated nipple wrenches in the past, I'd like to see your home made wrench if possible.

Good luck.
Click to expand...

I think I may end up trying the acetone/tranny fluid mix.

Here is a pic of my homemade nipple wrench. A dremel to 3/16" socket. Been using this or one like it for years. Much stronger than the store bought ones.

P2090576_zps9b1ed780.jpg


P2090575_zps8c3251e1.jpg
 
B

BirchOrr

New member
^^^
Yep, made one just like it only used a nutdriver instead of socket. Like to "feel" the nipple so I don't cross-thread the darned thing! :D You could easily put your socket on a nut driver handle....

Birch
 
U

UtahHunting

New member
Birch, I usually do have it on a nutdriver handle, I had it on the socket for extra torque to try and loosen the nipples. Very handy to have one and fits in the shooting box easily.
 
U

unknwn

New member
Put an extension on your socket/nipple tool , put the cylinder on a block of wood -or- similiar, put the tool on the nipple and hammer on it (the extension).
The -shock- of hammering on it will loosen it up almost every time.
If it didn't work, heat it up either with a propane torch or similiar -or- in a pan of boiling water -and- repeat the hammering trick again.
 
B

BirchOrr

New member
^^^
And... if any of the above works, put a touch of anti sieze grease on the threads with a Q-tip. Take the nipples out each time you clean the gun to keep it from happening again! :D

Birch
 
U

UtahHunting

New member
Was gonna say trans fluid and acetone, but I see that's already been covered. Its better than Kroil and much better than PB.
Click to expand...

I am going to try this, maybe as early as tomorrow. Just to be safe, this won't remove any of the finish on the cylinder will it?
 
B

BirchOrr

New member
I thought about that! To be safe use it on the INSIDE of the cylinder, not the outside. :D

Acetone is nasty stuff (nail polish remover). I use it to disolve contact cement when installing Formica countertops.

Birch
 
Last edited:
S

shortwave

New member
You may get by just soaking the cyl. in the ATF and leaving out the acetone.

Have had great result in the past doing this and letting the corroded part soak for a week or so agitating and wire brushing around the stuck part every day or so.
 
R

robhof

New member
robhof

I have used the acetone/auto trans fluid on my blued pistols with no ill effects, except it will fade cold blue and damage the fake case hardening that they have now. Good luck and keep us informed of your progress and a range report when successful.:D:cool:
 
D

DD4lifeusmc

New member
stuck nipple

I didn't read every reponse but.
Soak in the blaster or whatever for a couple days.
wipe out excess.
Use your homemade tool on and impact driver.
Type you hit with a hammer.
If that don't work.
Use a mini micro torch.
Heat only the cylinder all the way around the nipple.
Don't heat the nipple itself.
Now use the impact.
It should break loose.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top