My Next Rifle Purchase

[jackstrawIII]

Looking for some input on my next rifle purchase.

The Need:
- Lightweight rifle for deer hunting on my property. It's a wooded area with a few fields, but all shots would be significantly less than 100 yards.

Should I Buy:
- A lever action 30-30? It's a classic.
- A lever action 44 mag might work nicely. I could get a 44 mag pistol down the road and have some flexibility with the round.
- A used Savage 99 in 308? I have a really nice Savage Model 10 in 308 already that I use for long range shooting, but looking for something lighter and nimbler. 308 is probably overkill for short range, but it would work.
- Something else I haven't thought of?

I really like the idea of a lever action for quick handling and follow up shots (if necessary). I live in NY, so no ARs for me, unfortunately.

 

[Old Bill Dibble]

If all your shots will be under 100 yards on open fields a rifle may not be the best choice. A 20 gauge slug gun will help ensure that any missed rounds impact on your property instead of a neighbors.

If a shotgun is not an option than either the .44 magnum or the .30-30 would likely work equally well. The .44 won't travel as far and drop faster so I would favor that one. I would not bother with a scope either. At that range the scope will just slow you down over iron sights.

 

[Erno86]

I just received my lightweight CZ527 "M" Carbine in 7.62x39 last Saturday, and I had a chance to shoot a steel plate with it at 100 yards on Sunday. Tell you the truth...it is a handy little rifle, with mild recoil and a real fine trigger pull too boot. I love the little Mauser bolt, but I felt no need for them to put on a hair set trigger; though they said I could dismantle the set trigger. The iron sights were pretty much right on {comes with a three shot 50m target paper copy from the same rifle}, and the 16mm 1" Leupold scope rings {no need for polishing the rings} is going to fit my Vortex 2-8x that I just ordered.

Got it from Impact Guns for $600 + shipping.

 

[Blindstitch]

A 30-30 is a good option for the under 100 yard range. Ammo is cheaper and you can mount a scope on most of the new ones without a problem. That's if you want a scope.

My first deer rifle was a 1970's Winchester 30-30 and yes it has a scope on it. It did a great job for deer the first 5 years I hunted but now it's my back up rifle.

I have no problem using this rifle in hardwoods or thick brush but now half of my hunting is wooded areas along fields that you can see 300 yards.

I took my winchester out this past year for deer season sight in and my go to rifle was a click or two off but the 30-30 shot a dime size pattern with the first 3 shots at 50 yards.

 

[SRH78]

Honestly, for under 100 yards on deer, just buy whichever one you like best. They will all work great.

 

[40CalGuy]

i'd consider a firearm in a caliber common to another weapon that you may already have.

if you go with a centerfire bolt gun in a rifle caliber, my vote is a Tikka T3 Lite in whatever caliber is your preference.

 

[cw308]

Can't go wrong with a 30/30 in you area. When I was a kid in NYC my father would go hunting upstate. That Winchester mod.94 30/30 was a beautiful rifle. He never shot a deer, we use to go to a field in NJ set up some targets at about 75 yards. The rifle shot good, I was 12, the rifle at that age had a kick, even though just loved shooting it. Great rifle. His friend had a Marlin lever action 35 cal. Looks like time hasn't changed things when hunting Up State. Nice Place to Live. Be Safe.

 

[RC20]

Savage 243, BTH has a 22 inch barrel

will reach out easily to 200 yds just in case

 

[ms6852]

In a wooded area my choice for deer has always being a lever action, either caliber you mentioned will get the job done, but I prefer 30/30 simply because ammo is cheaper than 44 magnum but if it is flexibility you seek go 44 mag, you could hunt effectively with the pistol too, depending on length of barrel.

 

[jackstrawIII]

Erno86, I wasn't really considering a bolt gun, but that CZ 527 looks AWESOME. It's on the top of my list right now. I think I've narrowed this down to the 527 or some sort of 44/357 mag levergun.

 

[JWT]

A bit pricey, but the Winchester Model 73 in 38/357 is a very, very nice gun.

 

[std7mag]

I've been saving up for a Rossi 92 in 45 Colt...

Would do just what your asking for.

 

[Sgt Pepper]

Winchester 94 30/30 or Savage 99 in 300 Savage would be my vote. Lever action rules the day in compact size, slimness, handiness, lethality, and Americana goodness inside of 100 yards.

 

[jmr40]

None of those would be my top pick for pure performance.

All of those would be more than adequate and be classic rifles. Everyone should own a lever in 30-30. It is a rule you must have missed. I'd go that way but I've never owned one of the Savage 99's. That would be tempting as well if I could find a nice one I could afford.

 

[kraigwy]

You answered your own question.

Shoot less then 100 yards. 30-30 is perfect.

You really like lever actions. Again a near perfect rifle and there are several that come in the 30-30 round.

A tad off topic. My wife found and came home with a pre-64 (made in 1926) Model 94 Saddle ring Carbine in 30-30 (30 WCF). 18 inch barrel and excellent shooter. I have lots of guns but if I was to hunt deer and 100 yards or less, I'd steal that gun from her.

Granted its was probably more then what you'd want to pay for a hunting rifle but its slick.

Something I've noticed, being a Winchester gun. Model 94s are pricy now days, but I noticed that commutative rifles are often cheaper then the same standard 94, why I have no ideal. But something to think about.

 

[Targa]

I am with the lever action crowd as well given your uses for the rifle. As for chambering? Man that's tough, I have lever actions in both .44mag and 30-30, both will do the job very well. Like you mentioned, you can get a revolver to go with that .44. My 16" Rossi and 5.5" Ruger SBH are a favorite combo of mine at the range. But then again there is the iconic 30-30 deerslayer, I love shooting that Winchester. Decisions, Decisions..

Edit: I just noticed in another thread that you are pretty enamored by the CZ, don't see you going wrong there either, wouldn't mind one of those myself.

 

[44 AMP]

JackstrawIII, check your current game laws, and make sure a rifle is legal where you are.

I don't know what the laws are today, but I grew up hunting in "upstate" NY (the real upstate, north of Lake George, not the "upstate" of the Finger Lakes region, ), and at that time, deer hunting was divided into "northern" and '"southern" zones. Handguns and rifles were legal in the northern zone. The southern zone was shotgun ONLY, and for deer, SLUG only although buckshot or slug was legal for black bear.

The last time I hunted in northern NY was back in 78, and the game laws (including where the boundaries of each zone are) could have changed since then. A lot of other stuff has changed, so check CURRENT law.

Either a .44Mag or a .30-30 will do fine under 100yds, if legal. What more important is your ability.

 

[upstate81]

In new york the laws are set by county not zone. Most all counties now allow centerfire rifles. 44 amp, you should have hunted the finger lakes. The deer are bigger and much more abundant. They all eat corn, soy beans, and fruit. Not just pine cones and the flavor of the meat shows it. As to the original question, id likely not pick the 3030 or 44. Soley because it kind of backs you into a corner with performance. You may not think you need the extra range until you do!

 

[ammo.crafter]

under 100 yds

I absolutely enjoy hunting with my Thompson Contender; bot with rifle barrels and pistol barrels.

Check them out, you will have many caliber choices using one main frame.

 

[44 AMP]

In new york the laws are set by county not zone. Most all counties now allow centerfire rifles.

Good to hear most now allow rifles. I was hunting the Adirondacks back in the late 60s and early 70s. There was "northern zone" and "southern zone", and the rules were different in each (in those days). For example, in the southern zone you had to wear your tag on your back, in northern zone, you didn't have to wear it, just have it. Some counties contained both zones. Saratoga country was southern zone, south of Rt 40, northern zone, north of that, for example. Again, it was a long time ago, I'm sure much has changed.

Mother was a Town Clerk, and sold hunting licenses, Dad was NRA certified Hunter Safety, and Rifle & Pistol instructor. And, he worked for the state Conservation Dept. We were WELL instructed in the rules back then.