bamaranger
New member
Anybody using the "Smooth bullet sizer" from Hanks Precision Gun Parts, Dry Ridge KY????
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
muzzleloading bullet sizer
- Thread starter bamaranger
- Start date
http://swinglock.net/
Note that the T/C Maxi Ball is different diameters for a reason.
Pure lead will expand in diameter under enough pressure.
The die may be useful if bullets are oversize a lot.
Note that the T/C Maxi Ball is different diameters for a reason.
Pure lead will expand in diameter under enough pressure.
The die may be useful if bullets are oversize a lot.
Last edited:
bamaranger
New member
oversize
No problem with commercial, Maxiballs or Maxihunters. But they are getting hard to find and far too expensive when I do.
I've bought a REAL mold, cal.50 and am finding my cast slugs hard to seat, especially after the first one, despite swabbing. Problem could be my casting, but .32 Maxi's I make for a CVA seat and shoot well enough. Problem could be an over sized mold, lots of negative comments on Lee molds. But I thought I'd try it as they are so affordable.
The REAL's have an oversize engraving/driving band up front, I get it. I should measure the dia of a commercial Maxi v. my cast REAL's, that should tell me something. The "Smooth Die" is expensive, I could buy a real Maxi mold for about half the price.
The Smooth seems a nifty tool though.
No problem with commercial, Maxiballs or Maxihunters. But they are getting hard to find and far too expensive when I do.
I've bought a REAL mold, cal.50 and am finding my cast slugs hard to seat, especially after the first one, despite swabbing. Problem could be my casting, but .32 Maxi's I make for a CVA seat and shoot well enough. Problem could be an over sized mold, lots of negative comments on Lee molds. But I thought I'd try it as they are so affordable.
The REAL's have an oversize engraving/driving band up front, I get it. I should measure the dia of a commercial Maxi v. my cast REAL's, that should tell me something. The "Smooth Die" is expensive, I could buy a real Maxi mold for about half the price.
The Smooth seems a nifty tool though.
Jim Watson
New member
What diameter do you want? Lee makes bullet sizing sets for .501" and .510" but will make special order diameters.
Make sure the lead is pure. https://support.leeprecision.net/en/knowledgebase/article/oversized-bulletsJust a small % of antimony will increase diameters.
I use, scrub the bore with an oversize bronze brush before loading the next round.
More from Mr. Lee. https://support.leeprecision.net/en/knowledgebase/article/mold-diameter-tolerance
I use, scrub the bore with an oversize bronze brush before loading the next round.
More from Mr. Lee. https://support.leeprecision.net/en/knowledgebase/article/mold-diameter-tolerance
bamaranger
New member
diameters & antimony
Jim, I have not measured, so cannot answer accurately. The Smooth Die is adjustable, it appears the Swing-Lock maybe as well. As a general answer, I would like the diameter on my cast REALs, (the largest band) to be the same dia as commercial Maxi's, which seat easily. Again, I have not measured, oughta do that!
I suspect my REALs are oversize, due to lead/antimony mix as noted by 243winxb and likely to hot lead/mold temp as well. I seriously doubt my range & scrap lead is very pure. But I use the same Heinz Variety mix to do my .32's, and they seat fine........but the bore/slug tolerances in the .32 CVA may be larger.
I'll measure some tonight.
Jim, I have not measured, so cannot answer accurately. The Smooth Die is adjustable, it appears the Swing-Lock maybe as well. As a general answer, I would like the diameter on my cast REALs, (the largest band) to be the same dia as commercial Maxi's, which seat easily. Again, I have not measured, oughta do that!
I suspect my REALs are oversize, due to lead/antimony mix as noted by 243winxb and likely to hot lead/mold temp as well. I seriously doubt my range & scrap lead is very pure. But I use the same Heinz Variety mix to do my .32's, and they seat fine........but the bore/slug tolerances in the .32 CVA may be larger.
I'll measure some tonight.
bamaranger have you gotten the REAL to group worth a darn yet? I’ve tried it in .50 and results were abysmal. I don’t think it’s my casting (though I guess it could be) as I rejected every bullet dropped that didn’t have crisp lines and good mold fill. The .490 ball from the other cavity of that mold shoots quite well, though I’m aware PRBs are easier to get right. I guess I’ve chalked it up to the 1:48 twist that probably isn’t sufficient (though theoretically it should be).
Jim Watson
New member
REAL bullet bands are stepped in diameter, .50 spec is "Driving band diameters from the base of the bullet to the tip: .502, .507, .512, and .517."
A sizing die will make them all the same.
If you want to experiment, take a steel ruler or such and roll one on a hard surface with calipers at hand until it is the size you want. Tedious but cheap. I actually demonstrated this for a coworker whose Maxiballs just would not load and it let him get to shooting. I don't recall if he said how well.
A sizing die will make them all the same.
If you want to experiment, take a steel ruler or such and roll one on a hard surface with calipers at hand until it is the size you want. Tedious but cheap. I actually demonstrated this for a coworker whose Maxiballs just would not load and it let him get to shooting. I don't recall if he said how well.
REALS are supposed to be difficult to load since the rifling is engraved on loading, hence the name. If yours aren't pure lead they will come out of the mold oversize. That's not the molds fault. The harder lead is the less it shrinks on cooling, so if they're not pure lead they're going to be that much harder to seat.
Alloy bullets will appear frosted.
So will pure lead if it's too hot.
bamaranger
New member
groups
No, I am not satisfied with the REAL groups I'm shooting. The rifle is a T/C White Mtn carbine, w/ a peep, twisted 1:20. It shoots Maxi's of both description well enough to hunt, say 3 MOA, with 70 grains of 3F. The REALs are shooting twice that if not more. The carbine will not shoot round balls worth a hoot either, but that is no surprise. I have some heavy Lyman Great Plains, but cannot recall if I've ever shot them for group. I do recall the Great Plains were difficult to seat as well. I have no interest in shooting any type of sabot. For what it's worth, they have not shot all that well in my 1:48 Renegade either.
Casting REALS is a move towards economy. I really only use the White Moutain for hunting, and may have enough commercial/factory Maxi's to likely last. Store bought conicals are now incredibly expensive. If I improve my lead mix and casting, I would likely shoot the carbine more.
No, I am not satisfied with the REAL groups I'm shooting. The rifle is a T/C White Mtn carbine, w/ a peep, twisted 1:20. It shoots Maxi's of both description well enough to hunt, say 3 MOA, with 70 grains of 3F. The REALs are shooting twice that if not more. The carbine will not shoot round balls worth a hoot either, but that is no surprise. I have some heavy Lyman Great Plains, but cannot recall if I've ever shot them for group. I do recall the Great Plains were difficult to seat as well. I have no interest in shooting any type of sabot. For what it's worth, they have not shot all that well in my 1:48 Renegade either.
Casting REALS is a move towards economy. I really only use the White Moutain for hunting, and may have enough commercial/factory Maxi's to likely last. Store bought conicals are now incredibly expensive. If I improve my lead mix and casting, I would likely shoot the carbine more.
bamaranger
New member
measurements
I took my budget Frankford Arsenal digital mic to the REAL's. Largest (front) driving band measures .512-.513" , occasionally I'd get one a thousandth or so larger. Moving rearward, the bands are smaller, but I did not record them. I mic'd factory 370 gr Maxiballs, they went .506 at the front band, consistently. I also mic'd the Buffalo bullets (385 gr) and they went .512" up front.
So I'd say the REAL's and the Buffalo's are the same diameter, and my conclusion is that the REAL's are not particularly over size, being so near the same dia as the Buffalo bullets. I will keep trying to get the REAL's to shoot, maybe an over powder wad, and vary powder charge and type....we'll see. And I'll keep cleaning, and a mallet handy.
It's no wonder the Maxiballs seat easier, at .006+" smaller. Oddly, they shoot better too.
I took my budget Frankford Arsenal digital mic to the REAL's. Largest (front) driving band measures .512-.513" , occasionally I'd get one a thousandth or so larger. Moving rearward, the bands are smaller, but I did not record them. I mic'd factory 370 gr Maxiballs, they went .506 at the front band, consistently. I also mic'd the Buffalo bullets (385 gr) and they went .512" up front.
So I'd say the REAL's and the Buffalo's are the same diameter, and my conclusion is that the REAL's are not particularly over size, being so near the same dia as the Buffalo bullets. I will keep trying to get the REAL's to shoot, maybe an over powder wad, and vary powder charge and type....we'll see. And I'll keep cleaning, and a mallet handy.
It's no wonder the Maxiballs seat easier, at .006+" smaller. Oddly, they shoot better too.