Cowled_Wolfe
New member
Hello there. I've got a question which has been getting at me for what seems like ages...
With black powder, you measure by volume. With black powder substitutes, you measure by volume. With smokeless, you measure by weight... Why?
I've got two theories on the issue, but I don't have any certain knowledge:
1. Black powder and substitutes run at much lower pressures, so you can approximate the same weight each time if you go by volume -- in a smokeless rifle, an accidental extra grain or two might blow the rifle up.
2. Black powder and substitutes have some wierd physical property where one volume of powder will have the power of the same volume, even if they don't weight the same... One volume of smokeless will have the same power as another volume of powder only if they weight the same...
For some reason, the second theory seems wrong to me... But the first theory seems plausible... So what's the deal? Why is it volume for BP/substitutes and why is it weight for smokeless?
TIA for any info,
One very confused Wolfe...
With black powder, you measure by volume. With black powder substitutes, you measure by volume. With smokeless, you measure by weight... Why?
I've got two theories on the issue, but I don't have any certain knowledge:
1. Black powder and substitutes run at much lower pressures, so you can approximate the same weight each time if you go by volume -- in a smokeless rifle, an accidental extra grain or two might blow the rifle up.
2. Black powder and substitutes have some wierd physical property where one volume of powder will have the power of the same volume, even if they don't weight the same... One volume of smokeless will have the same power as another volume of powder only if they weight the same...
For some reason, the second theory seems wrong to me... But the first theory seems plausible... So what's the deal? Why is it volume for BP/substitutes and why is it weight for smokeless?
TIA for any info,
One very confused Wolfe...