I think I'm about to give up semi-autos

[kraigwy]

I do a lot of action pistol shooting, IPSC, IDPA. ICORE, Steel, etc etc.

Every other week our club has one of the above matches.

I've been going over the results of my shooting over the last couple years and it appears I can shoot my M-64 revolver better then any of my autos, I can't load as fast with speed loaders. Plus a 6 shot revolver is no match for my 18 rounds Beretta, in shooting steel, but the multi-round mags is ruining my shooting.

I don't care if I win or loose, I just care about my shooting, beating my last scores.

I'm going to back off autos for a while and stick to accuracy. Might even convert my M-64 to moon clips.

Anyone else feel that multi-cap semi autos is ruining your shooting?

 

[MGMorden]

Anyone else feel that multi-cap semi autos is ruining your shooting?

Can't say that I do. Personally while I like my revolvers (MAN its good being able to leave the range with ALL the brass I shot ), I can't shoot them well at speed. Getting a good shot with one (for me) requires either a pre-cock (slow and impractical for every shot), or slowing down so much and focusing on the trigger pull that its pointless.

Just for me, I'll shoot BETTER with the semi-autos every time. If it weren't for the brass retrieval situation I doubt I'd shoot my revolvers very often at all.

 

[mrt949]

I like shooting revolvers over bottom feeders any time. Less spray and pray.

 

[Don P]

Anyone else feel that multi-cap semi autos is ruining your shooting?

For me it doesn't matter. I'm ruining "my" shooting. I only own inaccurate guns, or is it me
If funds were better I would like to get my GP 100 machined for moon clips and give revolver a try. Can't do any worse than I do with semi-autos. I thought about red dot sights but all that will do is help me miss faster

 

[Jimro]

Well, you can shoot a revolver more accurately than a semi. Could be better grip and better sights.

As long as you are working on getting more accurate faster then I don't think it really matters what platform you are training on.

Jimro

 

[spacecoast]

Might even convert my M-64 to moon clips.

I think a moon-clipped 64 would be a great idea. If you get it done, please let us know where and how much. I might convert one of mine as well. Presumably all the machinist would need is the cylinder, correct? Would the ejector rod have to be shortened as well?

 

[Hunter Customs]

I don't know if a revolver is more accurate then a semi-auto but a revolver can be shot faster.
The reason for this is the cylinder has less travel time to the next chamber then a slide cycling a new round on a semi-auto.
Now for reloading, if you practice and get as good as Jerry Miculek you will beat a semi-auto in both cycling to the next round and reloading.
I do believe shooting a revolver can make a shooter more accurate, because you don't have the rounds to waste.
Best Regards
Bob Hunter
www.huntercustoms.com

 

[rjrivero]

I also prefer a good wheel gun to semi auto. I personally shoot my 625 in USPSA Revolver Class events. It's just more fun that way, imvho. Moon clips are the best invention since the metallic cartridge!

 

[Kimbertron]

I also prefer a good wheel gun to semi auto. I personally shoot my 625 in USPSA Revolver Class events. It's just more fun that way, imvho. Moon clips are the best invention since the metallic cartridge!

'

I started a thread about .45 acp revolver a week or so ago and that introduced me to the idea of moonclips. Since then i have been seeing them mentioned alot and im really starting to concider converting my sp101 carry gun to moonclips. I saw a video of someone (forget the name ill have to look it up) shooting 6 rounds on target, reloading, then shooting another 6 rounds on target in 2.9 seconds. It seemed like an older video and alot of people probably know who he is on here. I believe he was shooting a S&W 625 but im not sure. Long story long, it impressed me as i have never been able to get very fast with speed loaders.

 

[gunrobot]

I love shooting Revolvers and have been doing that for the past one year. I shoot a S&W 625 JM chambered in 45 ACP. It slows me down and makes me think about the plan and focus on accuracy instead of hosing.

 

[10-96]

This thread really makes me wish my local bullseye league would start having a stock revolver only night. That would be tons of fun, and I think some of the folks in the league would get some appreciation out of it too.

 

[rjrivero]

Jerry Miculek

I saw a video of someone (forget the name ill have to look it up) shooting 6 rounds on target, reloading, then shooting another 6 rounds on target in 2.9 seconds. It seemed like an older video and alot of people probably know who he is on here. I believe he was shooting a S&W 625 but im not sure. Long story long, it impressed me as i have never been able to get very fast with speed loaders.

No doubt Jerry Miculek. A freak of nature, that man.

 

[T. O'Heir]

"...don't care if I win or lose...just care about my shooting..." Throw in having fun and you're all set.
"...a revolver can be shot faster..." Nonsense.
"...on target in 2.9 seconds..." Jerry Miculek for sure, but he uses speed loaders.
"...as good as Jerry Miculek..." Classy guy, but a buddy of mine beat him in a man-on-man at Second Chance, long ago. Jerry had his hand out in congratulations before my buddy knew he had won. Class.

 

[Kimbertron]

"...on target in 2.9 seconds..." Jerry Miculek for sure, but he uses speed loaders.

No doubt Jerry Miculek. A freak of nature, that man.

Yup that was the one i went back and checked the name. Dont know if using speed loaders makes it any less impressive . Either way, that video lead me to many other of people competing with revolvers in compititions that i thought people only used semi autos for. I will admit im a bit sheltered in my corner of the world as i dont know alot of these big names in shooting. I guess that means i need more shooting buddies haha. Just started up another semester of school though so looks like ill be waiting until next summer to try a compitition. Time to buy some electric heated gloves for sub zero temp shooting and practice this winter.

 

[Hunter Customs]

"...a revolver can be shot faster..." Nonsense.
"...on target in 2.9 seconds..." Jerry Miculek for sure, but he uses speed loaders.

Sorry, but it's not nonsense that a revovlver can be shot faster then a semi-auto.

As for Jerry Miculek using speed loaders, that may have been true at one time.
However at the last American Handgunner World Shootoff I competed in, Jerry was using a revolver with moon clips.
No matter what Jerry uses the man is fast and good, this holds true with whatever firearm he shoots.

T. O'Heir, I take it you are a pin shooter?
Of all the different types of competition I've shot pin shooting is the one I miss most.

Best Regards
Bob Hunter
www.huntercustoms.com

 

[EdInk]

Miculek has used moonclips for at least the better part of a decade, probably even longer.

The revolver being faster than an auto depends on the guns in question. However, it is definitely the exception to the rule.

 

[wncchester]

"I think I'm about to give up semi-autos"

Okay. ??

 

[1SOW]

kraigwy:

Anyone else feel that multi-cap semi autos is ruining your shooting?

Keep shooting both.

"ARE YOU READY? STANDBY....BEEP" With action shooting, speed/time is a big issue in most scenarios. The "balance" between speed and accuracy drives the score. "Knowing" you have a high-cap mag may be a big part of the problem.

Try shooting your "pistol" slower. Purpously go for the same sight pic you get with your revolver and methodically press the trigger and then transition to the next target and do exactly the same. Think "every shot matters". Shoot with a slower rhythm. Do not double tap. Use a paced rhythm. Pop...pop.....pop...pop. When you have a 3yd point-shoot target blast away; but anytime your using the front sight be methodical and return to the pace.

Your times will(/maybe) slow down but your hits should improve. Practice the pacing using dryfire at home. When you get better than 90% "A-Zone" hits, speed up just a little with a slightly faster rhythm until you get back to 90% A-Zone hits, then slightly speed up again, etc. Pop..pop....pop..pop Your pacing will eventually catch up to your accuracy. Both can then start to improve.

Steel plate especially, use a rhythm/pace, ride the recoil to the next plate. EVERY shot matters. 6 plates = 6 shots, right?

Now that I've said all this, I'm not a great action shooter. I know some that are pretty good, and I'm regurgitating what they try to drive into my old brain. I may not have said it as well as they did/do.

Hope this helps.
The Brianenos forum has lots of good info on the mental and physical parts of the games.

 

[MLeake]

Depends on what you are competing in, I guess.

IDPA, extra rounds can be a gotcha, if you don't listen closely enough to the RO. If it's "Limited Vickers" instead of "Vickers" for the stage, then each extra round fired is a 5 second penalty... And each extra hit on target means the highest scoring one isn't counted, IE you take a time hit AND get your lowest hits scored.

I didn't understand the difference between "Vickers" and "Limited Vickers." Penalties suck.

Now, for unlimited Vickers, extra capacity is a good thing.

 

[MrBorland]

Now, for unlimited Vickers, extra capacity is a good thing.

eh...how so? Maybe if you think make-up shots are a good thing. A makeup shot is better than a miss, but many semi-auto shooters often take makeup shots whether they're needed or not. Or, they shoot a little sloppily because they have the capacity for makeups.

Here's the thing is, though; they're not free. Each one adds time, so a capacity advantage that allows one to get away with, say 6 reloads per match instead of 7 (wheelgunners) is insidiously chipped away by extra shots. Then they're surprised when a revolver shooter does well. What no one seems to realize is that at an IDPA match, the stages really aren't long enough for a good wheelgunner to be at a real disadvantage, compared to the semi-auto guys. For example, when I shot Expert in SSR, I was finishing with the top CDP Experts and right in with the ESP & SSP Experts. As an SSR Master, I do just as well against other Masters.

Unfortunately for many wheelgunners, they don't often see it this way, either, and they all too often buy into their own self-limiting "wheelgunner narrative" - that they're at a disadvantage, or matches aren't "revolver-friendly".

To Kraigwy - I dunno. The revolver has been good to me, and it seems to help my semi-auto shooting. As you know, revos teach the fundamentals well. I feel very fortunate to have (accidentally) started with one. A few weeks ago, I bought a Glock to try my hand at SSP. I took it to the range, dry fired it for about 10 minutes & worked on some "dry" reloads. Then, against the timer, I found I was immediately faster with it than with my revolver I'd worked so hard at being proficient with. Later that week, I shot a match (had to shoot unclassified) with it and was 2nd overall by 0.04 seconds. With a little practice I think I can kick some butt with it, and I have the wheelgun to thank for that. OTOH, I can see that too much of it might not be a good thing either. But I'm not worried, as there will always be room in my holster for a revolver.