Lame, lame, lame. Buncha rank amateur answers here.
Let the king cheep step in here...only Derby FALs came close, and
he was off by half... make a hole, fellas:
I clean all parts over a bread pan. (remember--'cheap' is the name of the game: Walmart's aluminum bread pan, about 10" x 6" x 4") Anything drips drips into the pan. Look up 'automotive paint supplies' in the phone book and go to one of the wholesaler suppliers and ask for some paper paint strainers. They'll strain lint fibers like you see floating in sun rays. Strain your used Hoppe's into a jar kept specifically for "used Hoppe's". After a few days, the remaining carbon sludge that strained through will settle on the bottom and you can pour off the clear Hoppe's into a squeeze bottle. I remember it used to look 90% as clean as new Hoppe's.
"Method Numbah Two" is
'way cheeper though.... use the same straining method with "Ed's Red".
Ed's works at least as well as Hoppe's and costs about 1/4 as much; I never sat down and compared final costs, but roughly, from below, ER costs ~ $15 per gallon; Midway sells #9 in quarts for $15. Without the lanolin ingredient added to Ed's Red, there's no purported lubrication. I use Mobil One for lubrication as a following step, anyway. Good enough for piston rings, good enough for me. My guns don't complain.
Ed's Red:
Makes slightly more than one (1) gallon of Ed's Red.
http://www.totse.com/en/politics/right_to_keep_and_bear_arms/eds_red.html or
http://www.flat5.net/eds_red.html
Ed's Red Notes
* 1 qt. ATF III (Automatic Transmission Fluid), Walmart automotive department, about $2.00
* 1 qt. Acetone, Home Depot paint department, $5.69 plus tax. (Probably also available at Walmart.) This ingredient is listed as "optional" in the original formulation -- it accelerates the cleaning action -- and is the most volatile [and hazardous] ingredient.
* 1 qt. Deodorized Mineral Spirits, Home Depot paint department, $3.69 plus tax. (Probably also available at Walmart.)
* 1 qt. K1 Kerosene. $3.20 (cash) for one gallon.
I read a tip somewhere once, and I'd bet money they're right--if you use acetone with your ER, store the mixture in a metal or glass container. DO NOT store it in anything made of plastics. It'll dissolve over time, and you'll have a soft, sludgy "bottle" with its' evident solvent leak.