"High End Modern" Bolt Guns

J

jackstrawIII

New member
I'm in the hunt for a new bolt gun and am looking for something with:
- fiberglass/kevlar/cf stock (it has to be thin in the wrist and forend)
- stainless everything (cerakoted stainless is fine)
- around 6-6.5 pounds bare
- if I could get a DBM, that would be great (hinged floorplate is an ok compromise)

I've owned a Kimber Montana and couldn't get it to shoot. I still have a Winchester Model 70 Extreme Weather and it's a nice gun but the Bell and Carlson stock is just too thick through the wrist/grip area for me to be really happy.

So I've been looking at some other higher cost stuff and people seem to have so many gripes about all of them. Here's what I've read:

- Montana Rifle Company X3 - too heavy and gritty receiver
- Christensen Arms Mesa - too flimsy in the stock and poor bolt clearance when scoped
- Nosler 48 - too blocky around the wrist/grip
- Cooper 54 - they use Bell and Carlson stocks (too thick)
- Sako Finnlite - injection molded stock

And on, and on. I can't tell if these are legit concerns, or if people are just being extra picky because of the price tag on these guns? I'd have to imagine they're not all THAT bad...

What are all your experiences with these, or other similar brands of rifles? I'd like to spend less than $2000. Should I just throw a Winchester 70 into a McMillan Edge stock and call it a day? Or is there something else out there that would give me what I'm looking for?

Thanks.
 
T

taylorce1

New member
Do you still have that M70 EW? If so buy a stock from McMillan, Wildcat Composites, or ect..., and problem is solved. If it were me I'd look at the Barrett Fieldcraft, it's a blind magazine which doesn't bother me at all.
 
J

jackstrawIII

New member
If it were me I'd look at the Barrett Fieldcraft, it's a blind magazine which doesn't bother me at all.
Click to expand...

The Barrett looks amazing to me... except the blind mag. That's a deal killer for me and the kind of hunting I do.
 
T

taylorce1

New member
Well a M70 EW in a McMillan Edge fill stock isn't going to be super light. My .270 weighs just over 8.5 lbs scoped with a VX3 3.5-10x40, leather shooting sling, and five rounds in the belly.

270.jpg


P1000619.jpg


A M70 FWT IN A McMillan Edge stock will be closer to what you want. My .30-06 is 7lbs 2 oz lbs scoped, but it's a blind mag. It'll probably be closer to 7.5 lbs with the factory bottom metal.

30-06.jpg


1359426492.jpg


You can always look for a used Howa Alpine, they had the choice of DBM or factory floorplate on them. I'm sure someone will build bottom metal for the Fieldcraft before too long.
 
D

dakota.potts

New member
I know a couple rifle builders who could give you exactly what you want, but you'd probably be spending $3,000-$4,000 instead of 2. Lightweight actions, carbon fiber barrels, and high-end stocks offer a lot of performance for the weight. 6 pounds on any system that accepts a DBM is going to be hard to do, especially if you don't like plastic.
 
J

jmr40

New member
My 308 Winchester EW with a McMillan Edge stock on it weighs 7.5 lbs including the Zeiss Conquest scope and Talley lightweight mounts. It is the most consistently accurate rifle I've ever owned. I won't say it is MOA all day long but is pretty close.

The scope is 15 oz add another 2-3oz for the mounts and figure the rifle alone at about 6.5 lbs or a little less. I liked the EW before the stock change. It is now my favorite rifle.

A standard weight McMillan or any other synthetic stock won't be any lighter than the B&C or any other wood stock. Get the Edge stock made with Kevlar if going McMillan.

Another option is the Tikka. Weight is about 6-6.5 lbs and they have DBM. Cost is about the same as a McMillan Edge stock. And the wait time on a McMillan is 3-4 months.

I'd bet money a $600 Tikka will outshoot most everything on your list.

The Barrett looks amazing to me... except the blind mag. That's a deal killer for me and the kind of hunting I do.
Click to expand...

I can't imagine any hunting situation where a blind mag would be the slightest handicap. It saves you 3-4 oz in weight, makes the stock stiffer, saves money, is one thing less to malfunction, and takes 2 seconds longer to unload at the end of the day.
 
L

LineStretcher

New member
Browning X Bolt you pick the one you like, they're all good.I should probably mention that I have the Hells Canyon Speed in 300 WSM but I also have an original pre Strategic Arms McMillan G30 Dynasty in 270 WSM that will go to the grave with me.
 
J

JRR

New member
You might take a look at the CZ557 with a Manners stock. Well within your budget and close to your ideal weight. 30-06, .270 and 6.5x55.
 
J

jackstrawIII

New member
Browning X Bolt you pick the one you like, they're all good.
Click to expand...

I've played with a few X Bolts and they've all felt great from a smoothness and balance standpoint... however, to my knowledge, all the new stainless X Bolts have the Dura-touch-whatever stock... which I do not like the feel of.
 
J

jackstrawIII

New member
A huge point in favor of the Montana X3 is that it’s avialble in 257 Roberts, which would be my caliber of choice. For those that have owned them, what’s your take on the X3? How does it compare to a Winchester 70 in terms of fit & finish?
 
M

MarkCO

New member
Weatherby Mark V Ultralight: http://www.weatherby.com/mark-vr-ultra-lightweight.html

Bergara Mountain: https://www.bergarausa.com/bergara_premier_series_mountain_rifle.php

Those are the two that check all of the boxes for me. They can be had for right around your max budget and are both phenomenal rifles. I have played with the Havak, the X3 and the Barrett, they are good, but the Weatherby and Bergara are better IMHO. I own one of the Weatherby's and have shot the Bergara's. Bergara Premiers are made in the US and are M700 footprint, so you get that benefit. Top quality and great customer service.
 
T

taylorce1

New member
I sent an inquiry to CDI precision about the Fieldcraft.

Hi….I don’t make one for it, but it may be very close to something else I have, and we may be able to make up a special part for it pretty easy.. takes a few weeks longer than normal install for engineering and finishing.. We can likely do it..thanks



Jeff





Jeffrey Allen
CDiPrecision Gunworks
1852 University Parkway
Sarasota Florida 34243
www.cdiprecisiongunworks.com
www.cdiprecisiongunworksstore.com
941-961-3185



From: <taylorce1@yahoo.com>
Sent: Thursday, September 27, 2018 10:15 PM
To: cdi@cdignition.com
Subject: DBM for the Fieldcraft?



Do you have any plans to make your bottom metal for the Barrett Fieldcraft?
Click to expand...

I had a Montana Rifle Company X2 rifle in .243 Win, and it was an extremely well put together rifle, but it was far to heavy. It came in a full pound over the projected weight after adding a fairly light scope and mounts. I never shot it and returned it for a refund, I would probably consider them again but just the barreled action or the action for a build.

I know they are an investment cast receiver so they're going to be heavier than a M70 action. I didn'texperience any grittyness in the action I had the bolt operated very smoothly. The other thing I like about them is the trigger and they fit the M70 footprint for stocks.
 
S

std7mag

New member
The Tikka is a good rifle, with excellent accuracy.
Ask Wendyj about them, as she has owned/does own several.

What about the Kimber Hunter in 257 Roberts?

Wish i had $2k to spend on a rifle!!
 
J

jackstrawIII

New member
The Tikka is a good rifle, with excellent accuracy.
Ask Wendyj about them, as she has owned/does own several.

What about the Kimber Hunter in 257 Roberts?

Wish i had $2k to spend on a rifle!!
Click to expand...

Yeah, I was very impressed by the Tikka I held the other day. The angular receiver is a bit weird, but I love the scope mount system.

Regarding the Kimber Hunter, it’s temptig, but I’ve had such hit/miss (more miss) experiences with the Kimber rifles.

And less than $2000 would be great haha.
 
S

Saltydog235

New member
My favorite rifle to carry without a wood stock is my Sako Finnlight in .300wm. Relatively lightweight, thinner foregrip and a palm-swell that fills out my grip. Shoots very well with the factory ammo I’ve been using, 180grn Sako Super Hammerheads, though the pigs don’t seem to like it much so far. It’s loaded down a bit though, working on a 165grn load for it now, just been too hot and the mosquitos have been too bad since Florence to do any Range work.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top