I bought a Pietta Griswold from Cheaper than Dirt. The photo on their site and on Traditions an importer of Pietta show the same photo. A straight cyl no roll mark no step up frame. What you get is a brass frame 1851 navy or 60 army type with a griswold round barrel. Not like the photo. If you just want to shoot no problem but if you want a closer reproduction to the G&G this aint what your going to get.
Heads up on Pietta Griswold
- Thread starter edteach
- Start date
OutlawJoseyWales
New member
Did the ad say you were going to get a .36 or a .44?
I'm sure you know that is the difference between the two pictures.
Is it possible they simply sent you the wrong pistol? However, most of these I've seen are the .44 cal ones like you had shipped to you.
I'm sure you know that is the difference between the two pictures.
Is it possible they simply sent you the wrong pistol? However, most of these I've seen are the .44 cal ones like you had shipped to you.
BlackPowderBen
New member
Cabelas has Griswold and Gunnison's in .36 caliber if that is what you're looking for.
Model12Win
Moderator
Looks close enough for the masses. Few care about historical correctivity.
Irish Jack
New member
I picked an 1851 .36 Mason Dixon Commemorative.It was made in 2002 by Armi San Marcus. It was in the box unfired. It has a nickle finish and I did not know it was a brass frame.
I bought it to shoot. I own many steel frame revolvers. But I would like advise on shooting this brass frame? Everything out there says they will shoot lose even with light loads.
I bought it to shoot. I own many steel frame revolvers. But I would like advise on shooting this brass frame? Everything out there says they will shoot lose even with light loads.
Cabela's states that one can no longer order the Pietta G&G .36 from their online store. Maybe give them a jingle at the 800 number.
http://www.cabelas.com/product/Piet...son-Caliber-Black-Powder-Revolver/1167468.uts
This next one, if still for sale, is a Pietta G&G .36 (2014 [CM] or earlier with the "tail grip, and I have no problem insofar as the "tail": it is a collector item from now on, since it is no longer being produced). For $185 + $15 shipping it looks like a deal to me if in like-new condition (nothing wrong with brass patina):
http://www.armslist.com/posts/15258...wold-and-gunnison--36-cal-percussion-revolver
Hawg is correct: his Pietta G&G .36 is a 2015 [CN] with the newer, more "conventional" grip style. Pietta no longer produces the "tail" profile. To my knowledge, Pietta never produced a G&G in .44.
My Pietta G&G .36 (2015 [CN]), just to state that at least two forum members have the same thing, and that it is not an anomaly. I paid $220 for it over a year ago from Cabela's:
Don't give up trying to acquire a Pietta G&G .36. If you have other Pietta 1851 Navy type pistols made after ~2000 (CNC machining), the G&G part round/part octagon barrel and the plain cylinder will allow you to create a Leech and Rigdon:
and other "fantasy" pistols, like my favorite 1851 Navy .36 Dragoon:
I would like to weigh in insofar as Pietta 1851 Navy type .44 pistols.
As Hawg would surely point out, no Pietta (or other) 1851 Navy replica type in .44 is historically correct.
However...
Pietta markets a "copy" of a J.H Dance and Brothers .44 pistol. The curious thing about this pistol is that it has been created using an 1851 Navy type steel frame, the cylinder is not rebated, and the water table is not cut for a rebated cylinder. However, the cylinder is much larger in diameter than a .36 Navy cylinder, so the water table must have been milled to fit and the bolt must have been modified. These parts are not interchangeable with any other Pietta 1851 Navy type pistol.
I have longed for a Dance .36, and why Pietta did not just mill off the ears of the recoil shields on their 1851 Navy steel frame, install a part round/part octagon .36 barrel (from G&G production) is beyond me. A genuine Dance .36 is rare but not unknown by far. And the parts would have been completely interchangeable between like Pietta 1851 pistols. As it is, it is one of a kind.
Collectible for that reason? Absolutely, but I don't want one.
And the prices I have seen for one of their Dance revolvers is just obscene to me.
http://www.dixiegunworks.com/product_info.php?products_id=883
http://www.taylorsfirearms.com/1862-dance-revolver-pietta.html
Sorry, I digress from the OP.
Jim
http://www.cabelas.com/product/Piet...son-Caliber-Black-Powder-Revolver/1167468.uts
This next one, if still for sale, is a Pietta G&G .36 (2014 [CM] or earlier with the "tail grip, and I have no problem insofar as the "tail": it is a collector item from now on, since it is no longer being produced). For $185 + $15 shipping it looks like a deal to me if in like-new condition (nothing wrong with brass patina):
http://www.armslist.com/posts/15258...wold-and-gunnison--36-cal-percussion-revolver
Hawg is correct: his Pietta G&G .36 is a 2015 [CN] with the newer, more "conventional" grip style. Pietta no longer produces the "tail" profile. To my knowledge, Pietta never produced a G&G in .44.
My Pietta G&G .36 (2015 [CN]), just to state that at least two forum members have the same thing, and that it is not an anomaly. I paid $220 for it over a year ago from Cabela's:
Don't give up trying to acquire a Pietta G&G .36. If you have other Pietta 1851 Navy type pistols made after ~2000 (CNC machining), the G&G part round/part octagon barrel and the plain cylinder will allow you to create a Leech and Rigdon:
and other "fantasy" pistols, like my favorite 1851 Navy .36 Dragoon:
I would like to weigh in insofar as Pietta 1851 Navy type .44 pistols.
As Hawg would surely point out, no Pietta (or other) 1851 Navy replica type in .44 is historically correct.
However...
Pietta markets a "copy" of a J.H Dance and Brothers .44 pistol. The curious thing about this pistol is that it has been created using an 1851 Navy type steel frame, the cylinder is not rebated, and the water table is not cut for a rebated cylinder. However, the cylinder is much larger in diameter than a .36 Navy cylinder, so the water table must have been milled to fit and the bolt must have been modified. These parts are not interchangeable with any other Pietta 1851 Navy type pistol.
I have longed for a Dance .36, and why Pietta did not just mill off the ears of the recoil shields on their 1851 Navy steel frame, install a part round/part octagon .36 barrel (from G&G production) is beyond me. A genuine Dance .36 is rare but not unknown by far. And the parts would have been completely interchangeable between like Pietta 1851 pistols. As it is, it is one of a kind.
Collectible for that reason? Absolutely, but I don't want one.
And the prices I have seen for one of their Dance revolvers is just obscene to me.
http://www.dixiegunworks.com/product_info.php?products_id=883
http://www.taylorsfirearms.com/1862-dance-revolver-pietta.html
Sorry, I digress from the OP.
Jim
Last edited:
@hellgate:
Do yourself a favor and buy or borrow a copy of " '51 Colt Navies" by Nathan L. Swayze (1967), replete with all photos of originals, no repros.
After that, come back and tell us all what the correct shape and configuration of 1851 Navy Colts are. Notice the differences in the trigger lengths, also.
Looking forward to that.
Here is just a sample (and please read the comments about the other differences in these Third Model pistols from the author):
Chuckle.
Jim
Do yourself a favor and buy or borrow a copy of " '51 Colt Navies" by Nathan L. Swayze (1967), replete with all photos of originals, no repros.
After that, come back and tell us all what the correct shape and configuration of 1851 Navy Colts are. Notice the differences in the trigger lengths, also.
Looking forward to that.
Here is just a sample (and please read the comments about the other differences in these Third Model pistols from the author):
Chuckle.
Jim
Last edited:
Bishop Creek
New member
Harpers Weekly ad from 1863 showing strange grips:
I made the mistake of saying they did once and was quickly trounced upon and told it was a Reb Navy. That is how they advertised it but it's still a .44 G&G. The new grip profile is closer to a Colt grip than anything they did before. Yes Colt had a little flare on the back strap for awhile but not the deep curve on the front strap that gave them the trumpet shape.
Well, sir, I really don't want to ruffle your feathers, but you seem to be a cheap date, even though you probably got the most you could in this situation.
Please hear me out, sir.
You now own a 1851 Navy type .44 brasser. It is no where near the G&G .36 you were looking for, and is no way anywhere near an historical C&B pistol. As a shooter it will only survive with small loads (compared to a Navy steel frame).
And you are now in possession of a CTD gift certificate that can only be spent at CTD.
Use it and buy some ammo for any centerfire pistol or rifle you have and be done with CTD. As another poster has stated with CTD, basically fuggetaboutit.
There have been other links posted in this thread about other better sources for a Pietta G&G .36.
I wish you luck with your G&G search.
Jim