Gary L. Griffiths
New member
There is a thread over on THR about case capacity/weight of commercial vs military .223/5.56mm cases, so just for gits and shiggles, I spent a rainy yesterday morning doing some weighing and measuring. From my reloading bench, I selected lots of 5 cases each of resized, trimmed and primed brass from Federal, PMC Bronze, PPU Match, and PMC X-Tac as well as 5 unfired primed Lake City 13 cases. First, I measured case capacity using some BLC(2) powder by filling the case to overflowing, then leveling the mouth with the edge of my scales powder pan. I poured each charge into the pan and weighed them with the following average weights (in grains):
Federal, 30.84, SD 0.30; PMC Bronze, 30.95, SD 0.37; PPU Match, 30.30, SD 0.31; PMC X-Tac, 30.19, SD 0.41; Lake City 30.16, SD 0.61.
Primed case weights: Federal, 96.12, SD 0.48; PMC Bronze, 96.46, SD 0.13; PPU Match, 98.17, SD 1.06; PMC X-Tac, 96.40, SD 0.49; Lake City 96.10*, SD 0.52. *Adjusted for weight difference of 0.2 gr. between CCI 400 and CCI 41 primers.
Case lengths: Federal, 1.7497", SD 0.0055; PMC Bronze, 1.7554", SD 0.0023; PPU Match, 1.7540", SD 0.0031; PMC X-Tac, 1.7540", SD 0.0022; Lake City, 1.7538; SD 0.0007.
Correlation of case weight to case capacity: Federal -0.51; PMC Bronze -0.06; PPU Match +0.44; PMC X-Tac -0.68, Lake City -0.42.
Bottom Line: Lake City cases don't have significantly less capacity than commercial cases, and there is no real correlation between case weight and capacity.
FWIW
Federal, 30.84, SD 0.30; PMC Bronze, 30.95, SD 0.37; PPU Match, 30.30, SD 0.31; PMC X-Tac, 30.19, SD 0.41; Lake City 30.16, SD 0.61.
Primed case weights: Federal, 96.12, SD 0.48; PMC Bronze, 96.46, SD 0.13; PPU Match, 98.17, SD 1.06; PMC X-Tac, 96.40, SD 0.49; Lake City 96.10*, SD 0.52. *Adjusted for weight difference of 0.2 gr. between CCI 400 and CCI 41 primers.
Case lengths: Federal, 1.7497", SD 0.0055; PMC Bronze, 1.7554", SD 0.0023; PPU Match, 1.7540", SD 0.0031; PMC X-Tac, 1.7540", SD 0.0022; Lake City, 1.7538; SD 0.0007.
Correlation of case weight to case capacity: Federal -0.51; PMC Bronze -0.06; PPU Match +0.44; PMC X-Tac -0.68, Lake City -0.42.
Bottom Line: Lake City cases don't have significantly less capacity than commercial cases, and there is no real correlation between case weight and capacity.
FWIW