Car gun reliability

cnemeth

New member
Would the normal stop and go movements and vibrations of a car/truck affect the ammo in a pistol magazine? Specifically could the ammo shift position in a magazine enough to case feeding issues?
 

Onward Allusion

New member
Unless you're going off-roading and even then, your mags are going to be fine. I've had loaded mags in my trunk for years and they always shot fine when I rotated out the ammo.
 

cslinger

New member
I don’t have a car gun so to speak but I seriously doubt it. I would imagine the ammo in a mag gets more jostled in day to day carry and administrative handling then in driving, unless you are desert running. :)

What I would worry about with a polymer frame Gun would be the constant heat and cooling cycles on the ammo and polymer if a polymer framed Gun although I suspect both would be fine for a good long time.
 

HistoryJunky

New member
I have a revolver as my "car gun" but no real reason for it. They would not be subjected to the issues you speak of though.

I just keep my .357 in my vehicle because I go shooting after work at a local range fairly often.

Sent from my SM-G930R4 using Tapatalk
 

Don P

New member
I remember on the guns and ammo show the 2 guys who did the gun torture tests taking a polymer gun and putting it on a BBQ grill and cooking it. IIRC it was a XD and all that happened was a slight mark in the grip from the grates. Gun shot just fine
 

JC57

New member
If I am not mistaken, most police officers carry firearms and magazines on their belts while driving or riding in cars (or motorcyles) most days, so they are subjected to the jostling around of the car as well as all of the movements of a person getting in and out of the car.

I think you are worried about a non-issue.
 

bn12gg

New member
Eh, go with a short barreled revolver in .38. My choice SW M10 with 6 rounds tactical .38. No feeding issues.

.02. David. :cool:
 

Carmady

New member
Would the normal stop and go movements and vibrations of a car/truck affect the ammo in a pistol magazine?

I doubt if the military would use magazines if that was a probability.
 
Vibration from riding around in a vehicle can loosen screws that are not loctited. I’ve seen everything from sight mounts to pistol grips and AR buffer tubes back out as a result. I don’t think most pistols have much that could work loose aside from a grip panel; but with the increased use of red dots, sight mounts might still be an issue.
 

K_Mac

New member
I can't imagine it would be an issue with normal attentiveness. Any defensive weapon needs to be shot and maintained on a regular basis, especially one that is carried in my opinion. That includes revolvers. Yes, I know there are some who've been carrying the same ammo since the seventies, but whether it is on my belt or in my truck, I shoot it and replace it every couple of months at least. That and a regular wipe down and inspection are my minimum standards.
 

JohnKSa

Administrator
As part of a test on ammo, I left some loaded magazines in my car 24/7/365 for at least two years. The ammo was premium self-defense ammunition and although I didn't chronograph it, it seemed to be unaffected and all of it fired with no detectable issues. The magazines worked just fine.

I didn't just throw the mags into the trunk at let them rattle around. They were in a typical zip-up soft gun case and placed in the car so that the case was not moving around or having things bump into it.

That was with one type of ammunition and one type of magazine, so I can't say that any ammunition or magazines would be unaffected, but I think that any high-quality ammunition and decent quality magazines are likely to do just fine in the kind of conditions I describe above.
 

Drm50

New member
I logged a lot of bone jarring miles in tracks and never had any problem with
GI 1911 pistols or magazines. It might help them from taking a set from non
use. Unlike truck guns we did have to clean 1911s daily because of the humidity
and dust.
 

agtman

Moderator
I logged a lot of bone jarring miles in tracks and never had any problem with GI 1911 pistols or magazines. It might help them from taking a set from non-use. Unlike truck guns we did have to clean 1911s daily because of the humidity and dust.

1911s need a lot of attention to keep them running. :rolleyes:

For a 'banged-around' car gun, a Glock or revolver is the better choice.
 

Drm50

New member
There is always one in the crowd. A Glock won't rust, I give you that. Which is only benifit.
1911s take a licking and keep on ticking. 107 years and still going strong.
 

agtman

Moderator
A Glock won't rust, I give you that. Which is only benefit.
1911s take a licking and keep on ticking. 107 years and still going strong.

Maybe WW1 & WW2 1911s. :rolleyes:

Modern ones, with tight tolerances, seem to be incredibly reliable only if kept in the back of the safe. ;) :eek:

Get a Glock for a car gun. If you ever need it, you can thank me later. :cool:
 
Top