Smaug:
I guess perhaps the 3rd generation Smith & Wesson pistols are an acquired taste.
When you have the time, and if you have the interest, please use the "search" or "find" function on the gun forums for 3rd gen Smiths and see what you find. I can assure you that absolute reliability, very good self defense accuracy, and fantastic durability are the qualities of the 3rd Generation Smith & Wesson pistols that many folks appreciate.
For me personally my number ONE requirement in a personal protection firearm is RELIABILITY... I doubt any modern plastic gun has a better long term reputation for absolute reliability than the 3rd gen Smiths. Reliability is vastly more important to me personally than capacity, even accuracy. I want my defense weapon to work every time.
I've owned a 3913 since 1995. It has never burped once in 13 years. The 5906 and 6906 S&W pistols were standard issue to thousands of leo's for years and years, and had a fine reputation for excellence in service.
But what a person prefers in a firearm is strictly personal.. Subjective, not objective...
These 3rd generation Smiths have been discontinued.. I spoke to a senior Customer Service person before I bought my 6906 to ask him his opinion of the 3rd gen Smiths, and he said "they were the absolute best pistols Smith & Wesson ever made, or is making"....
I wanted to get all I wanted while the "getting is good".. And I found out the "getting is good" supply is thinning out very quickly on the new 6906's and 3913LS pistols already.
I've had a pretty good batch to compare them too.. Glock/Sig/HK/Beretta/Star/Bersa/Walther/KelTec/Browning/ect. and while each of those pistols had something to offer I liked, NONE of them as an overall package were any better, and generally not as good as the 3rd gen. Smith.
To give you an idea of MY personal love for these pistols, I have recently sold a Walther PPS to finance my 3913LS. I will shortly probably sell my Walther P99/AS (which is a fine pistol by the way) because my 5906 can do the same job as the Walther, but my wife shoots it well, and I can get CT Lasergrips for it, and not the P99..
Not trying to be a smart butt, or offend you, but I'm a senior citizen, and I've owned, or fired, a pile of pistols in my over half a century of owning & shooting them.. I know what I like, and I know how the 3rd gen Smiths compare to most of the competition..
I will admit that I have never considered the 3rd gen Smith pistols (I've owned) quite as accurate as say my HK P7, but they are absolutely self defense accurate, and the difference in accuracy between the fine P7 and the 3913 at self defense range is only in the size of the group in the X ring..
I can take a slightly larger group as long as that group resides in the ten ring.
Again, no offense intended.
Best Wishes,
Jesse