A durable blue finish is long overdue!

Murdock

New member
Back when the stainless steel S&W M60 came out, I remember everybody wanting one, and prices getting high among the police crowd. My father was the president of our local police reserve organization, and he used to tell about cops trying to talk each other out of M60s as soon as anybody laid hands on one. The competition among buyers to actually own one was similar to that for the .44 magnum M29, also a tough gun to find at a reasonable price at that time.

The Chief's Special M36 was very popular all by itself, but the M60 was the Holy Grail because of that magical and unique stainless construction. Gun writers of the era were testing the guns by dunking them in seawater and then cleaning them in their household dishwashers, then writing it all up for those of us out in the provinces who had only read about these mythical guns.

Stainless steel handguns are old hat now, and it would be strange to go into a gun shop and not see any on display.

But it seems that a preponderance of gun fanciers always prefer the appearance of blue steel over stainless. There are attractive stainless finishes to be sure, in any level of shine desired, but I believe blue is cherished for it's inherent beauty, and stainless more for its durability.

Why can't we have a truly durable blue finish? One that could simply be polished by hand to get a scratch out, and that would not be marred by a holster? Would it be possible to have a blue steel that is simply made blue through and through?

Is there a bake-on or some other application type of finish that really comes close to this concept? A finish where the surface gleams like like the paint job on a Porsche Carrera but is tough? One that could be refreshed easily by the owner? If so, which one?

If there was a magical, "eternal" blue would that ruin the very idea of bluing as an attractive finish? Is the essence of blue's beauty its fragility, its temporary nature, like the beauty of Autumn? :(
 

natjohnb

New member
I am also a big fan of blued guns. Stainless is nice, but blue is nicer IMO.

I really do wish the bluing was more durable on most guns. For example, my SW1911 is beautiful and I love it; however, the blue finish S&W put on it is too thin and easily marred.

check out my 1911 that is less than one year old...

HPIM0630.jpg


HPIM0631.jpg


:(:barf::mad:
 

azredhawk44

Moderator
The top half of my Sig GSR is a Nitride finish:
P1010038.jpg


It's not really a "blue" though, I think. More of a powdercoat. I had an old Charles Daly re-finished by Arizona Expert Arms... I had worn the original bluing completely off in many places from lots of hiking and summer shooting in Arizona summers (sweat!). I don't have a pic right now, but if you're really interested, PM me and I'll set one up. It is a finish they call "parkote" that looks like a hybrid blue/nitride.

I wouldn't expect it to hold up on a revolver though... especially with the drag line area on the cylinder.
 

Mark Milton

Moderator
Bluing is a form of controlled rust. Thats why you will never see a durable blued finish....

I think what you want would be a black chrome.
 

20nickels

New member
Ford's in Florida is known to do very fine bluing (is that a word?). I'm sure it isn't any more durable however.
 
Top