5904 or p85

[stillquietvoice]

First off Its been more than 10 years since I've had an auto pistol for defense or carry. My last carry gun was a para p14 45. I have fired a friends m&p shield, but prefer a full size gun.
Which of these do you think will be the better choice. Does either have any serious flaws to be early of.
Thank you for your wisdom.

 

[Whirlwind06]

The S&W is a lot smaller then the p85 (I assume you mean Ruger p85) if you are open to other TDA pistols I would suggest the Beretta Px4 or CZ 09 or 07

 

[Mosin44az]

The Ruger P85 had a safety-related recall. I believe if the one you are considering has been corrected it should say “ Mark II” on the slide or similar. Check with Ruger, they will fix for free.

Odd choice you have, almost a time warp from the 80’s. Both should function OK, the Smith is slimmer and should have more collector value.

 

[stillquietvoice]

I started shooting pistols in the mid 80's, not up on the latest and greatest. Not a fan of do pistols either. Like heavier guns for punching paper... Plus a local shop has both for 400 or less.
I had 2 Taurus 99 ads a star 30 and a p14. The p14 was most accurate.

 

[4719]

I would go with the 5904. Carried the 5903 in the 90's, and it was very reliable.

 

[muzzleblast...]

Personally, I'd go with the 5904. Nothing against the metal framed Ruger P series, but the S&W semi-autos began in the late 1950s and evolved until the 3rd generation series and are well proven designs.

 

[kymasabe]

Having owned similar guns, my nod goes to the 5904. Lighter, slimmer, more refined, reliable as heck. I like the Ruger as well but if given a choice, I'd reach for the s&w.

 

[wnycollector]

Another vote for the 5904.

 

[rock185]

I had a Ruger P85, and several S&Ws semi-autos. I would would pick the 5904 without hesitation.....ymmv

 

[dgludwig]

I'm a big fan of Smith 3rd Generation pistols; a Model 6906 was my duty weapon for a couple of decades. Very rugged and reliable pistols. I have nothing against the Ruger but I have no experience with the P85 model.

 

[stillquietvoice]

Well I made the 80 mile round trip and bought the Smith. It will be a couple weeks before I can pick it up. NY run around putting it on my permit. Will update and give range report then.
Thank you all for your help.