Choosing the right subcompact pistol can be a tough decision, especially when comparing two highly-rated models from the same manufacturer. The SIG Sauer P365 and P365XL are both popular choices for concealed carry, but they offer distinct features that cater to different preferences and needs. This in-depth comparison will help you determine which pistol best suits your shooting style and carry requirements.
Size and Weight: The Key Differentiator
The most significant difference between the P365 and P365XL lies in their dimensions. The XL model boasts a longer grip and slide, resulting in a noticeably larger overall footprint.
-
P365: Known for its remarkably compact size, making it ideal for deep concealment. Its smaller size, however, translates to a shorter grip, which can impact shootability for users with larger hands.
-
P365XL: The extended grip and slide offer a more substantial feel, improving control and reducing felt recoil. This translates to a more comfortable shooting experience, especially during extended range sessions. The added length also contributes to slightly increased accuracy.
Capacity: More Rounds in the XL
While both pistols utilize the same width magazines, the XL's extended grip allows for an increased round capacity.
-
P365: Standard capacity is 10+1 rounds, though higher-capacity magazines are available.
-
P365XL: Standard capacity is 12+1 rounds, again with higher capacity options on the market. The increased capacity offers a significant advantage in self-defense situations.
Shootability and Recoil: A Matter of Preference and Hand Size
The added length and weight of the P365XL contribute to a more manageable recoil impulse. This enhanced control makes it a more comfortable pistol for extended shooting sessions and for those with smaller hands who might find the P365's recoil more pronounced.
-
P365: Its compact size can lead to snappier recoil for some shooters. Those with larger hands might find the grip a bit too small for optimal control.
-
P365XL: The longer grip and slide provide better leverage and a more balanced feel, reducing felt recoil and improving overall accuracy.
Concealability: The P365 Takes the Lead
Concealment is a primary consideration for many subcompact pistol owners. In this area, the P365's smaller profile provides a distinct advantage.
-
P365: Its diminutive size makes it easy to conceal, even under lightweight clothing.
-
P365XL: While still concealable, the increased size of the XL makes it slightly more challenging to carry discreetly, particularly for individuals with smaller builds.
Features and Accessories: Near Identical
Both pistols share many features, including SIG's excellent trigger, nitron finish, and compatibility with a wide range of aftermarket accessories like holsters, sights, and lights.
The Verdict: Choosing the Right P365 for You
The best choice between the SIG Sauer P365 and P365XL depends entirely on individual needs and preferences.
-
Choose the P365 if: You prioritize maximum concealability above all else, and you’re comfortable with a more compact grip.
-
Choose the P365XL if: You value improved shootability, reduced recoil, and a higher magazine capacity.
Ultimately, handling both pistols is highly recommended before making a decision. Visit your local gun store to test fire each model and determine which one feels best in your hand and meets your specific needs for concealed carry and shooting performance. Consider factors like hand size, shooting experience, and desired level of concealability to make the most informed choice.
