Choosing between the Ruger GP100 and the Smith & Wesson 686 is a classic dilemma for revolver enthusiasts. Both are renowned for their reliability, durability, and accuracy, but subtle differences cater to specific preferences and needs. This in-depth comparison will help you decide which iconic revolver best fits your shooting style and requirements.
Key Differences: A Head-to-Head Look
Both the Ruger GP100 and Smith & Wesson 686 are .357 Magnum revolvers capable of firing .38 Special ammunition. However, several key distinctions set them apart:
1. Frame Material and Construction:
-
Ruger GP100: Typically features a robust stainless steel construction known for its resilience and resistance to wear and tear. Ruger's construction is often praised for its ruggedness, making it ideal for harsh conditions.
-
Smith & Wesson 686: Also commonly made from stainless steel, the 686 boasts a slightly more refined feel. The differences are subtle but noticeable to experienced shooters. S&W's designs often emphasize a balance between strength and elegance.
2. Action:
-
Ruger GP100: Employs a strong, reliable double-action/single-action (DA/SA) mechanism. Ruger's actions are known for their smooth operation, even after extensive use.
-
Smith & Wesson 686: Also features a DA/SA action. The 686's action is often described as having a slightly lighter and crisper trigger pull in single-action mode, though this can vary depending on the specific gun and its condition.
3. Weight and Balance:
-
Ruger GP100: Generally heavier than the 686, contributing to greater recoil absorption and improved stability during rapid fire.
-
Smith & Wesson 686: Lighter than the GP100, offering potentially better handling and maneuverability for some shooters. This lighter weight can, however, lead to more felt recoil.
4. Trigger:
As mentioned above, the trigger pull is a subjective area. Both offer smooth double-action and single-action modes, but individual guns can vary greatly in trigger feel. Aftermarket trigger jobs are common for both models to enhance performance.
5. Sights:
Both revolvers usually come equipped with adjustable rear sights, allowing for precise zeroing. However, specific sight options might differ depending on the model and configuration.
6. Price:
Pricing varies depending on retailer and specific model, but generally, both revolvers fall within a similar price range. Used models of both can offer significant savings.
Which Revolver is Right for You?
The "best" revolver depends on individual needs and preferences.
Choose the Ruger GP100 if:
- You prioritize ruggedness and durability above all else.
- You prefer a heavier revolver for better recoil management.
- You anticipate using your revolver in demanding conditions.
Choose the Smith & Wesson 686 if:
- You value a slightly lighter and potentially more maneuverable firearm.
- A lighter trigger pull in single-action mode is a priority for you.
- You prefer a more refined feel and aesthetic.
Ultimately, handling both the Ruger GP100 and the Smith & Wesson 686 is highly recommended before making a decision. Visit a local gun store and compare the two firsthand to determine which feels better in your hand and suits your shooting style. Remember to always prioritize safety and follow all local firearm regulations.
