Choosing between the Mossberg 590A1 and the Remington 870 is a common dilemma for shotgun buyers. Both are legendary pump-action shotguns with a rich history and robust reputations, but they cater to slightly different needs and preferences. This detailed comparison will help you decide which shotgun is the right fit for you.
Key Differences: Design and Features
Both shotguns are built to last, but their designs differ in several key aspects:
Action Bar and Follower:
-
Mossberg 590A1: Features a dual-action bar system, offering increased reliability and smoother operation, especially under stress. The anti-jam design is a significant advantage. The follower design also prevents the last shell from being pinched, improving reliability further.
-
Remington 870: Employs a single action bar. While perfectly reliable for most users, it can be slightly more prone to malfunctions if not maintained meticulously, or under extreme use. The follower design is simpler, but less resistant to shell-feeding issues in certain circumstances.
Safety:
-
Mossberg 590A1: Has a tang safety located conveniently behind the trigger guard. This is generally considered more accessible and intuitive for many shooters.
-
Remington 870: Features a cross-bolt safety located on the trigger guard. While functional, it can take some getting used to, particularly for those accustomed to tang safeties.
Ejection Port:
-
Mossberg 590A1: The ejection port is slightly larger than the 870's, allowing for easier clearing of malfunctions.
-
Remington 870: The smaller ejection port is generally not a problem, but some users might find it slightly less convenient.
Magazine Tube Capacity:
Both shotguns offer various magazine tube capacities depending on the model and barrel length, making direct comparison tricky. However, both brands provide models with similar capacities to fit various needs.
Accessories and Customization:
Both shotguns have extensive aftermarket support, with countless accessories available for customization. However, some users argue that the Mossberg 590A1 might have a slightly wider range of readily available aftermarket parts due to its simpler, more modular design.
Performance and Reliability: A Head-to-Head
Both the Mossberg 590A1 and the Remington 870 are renowned for their rugged reliability. In typical use, both will function flawlessly. However, anecdotal evidence and some testing suggest the Mossberg 590A1's dual-action bar design provides a slight edge in reliability, especially under harsh conditions or with heavy use. The differences are marginal for most users, though.
Price Point: A Considerate Factor
Generally, the Mossberg 590A1 tends to be slightly more affordable than the Remington 870, especially in comparable configurations. However, this can vary based on retailer, specific model, and market conditions.
The Verdict: Which Shotgun Reigns Supreme?
There isn't a single "better" shotgun; the ideal choice depends on individual needs and preferences.
-
Choose the Mossberg 590A1 if: You prioritize a slightly more robust and reliable action, prefer a tang safety, want a larger ejection port, and are looking for a potentially more budget-friendly option. The slightly more accessible aftermarket may also be appealing.
-
Choose the Remington 870 if: You prefer the feel and handling of the Remington 870, are comfortable with a cross-bolt safety, and are not overly concerned about the marginal differences in action reliability. The long history and reputation of the 870 might also sway some buyers.
Ultimately, handling both shotguns and considering your specific needs – whether for home defense, hunting, or other applications – is crucial for making the right decision. Visit your local gun store to personally assess each option before making a purchase.
