The Smith & Wesson Model 19 is a legendary revolver, and the Carry Comp variant adds an intriguing twist. This review delves into the performance, practicality, and overall experience of owning and shooting this classic firearm with a modern upgrade. We’ll explore its strengths and weaknesses, helping you decide if it’s the right firearm for you.
What is the Model 19 Carry Comp?
The Model 19 Carry Comp is essentially a Smith & Wesson Model 19 revolver equipped with a compensator. This compensator is designed to reduce recoil and muzzle rise, enhancing both accuracy and shootability. The Model 19 itself is a K-frame .357 Magnum revolver, known for its robust construction and reliable performance. The addition of the compensator caters to shooters seeking a more controlled shooting experience, particularly in rapid fire situations.
Performance Analysis: Accuracy, Recoil, and Handling
The Model 19 Carry Comp shines in several key performance areas:
Recoil Management:
The most significant benefit of the compensator is its effective recoil reduction. While not eliminating recoil entirely, it noticeably mitigates muzzle jump, allowing for faster target reacquisition and improved follow-up shots. This is particularly advantageous for less experienced shooters or those prioritizing rapid fire accuracy.
Accuracy Enhancement:
Reduced recoil translates directly to improved accuracy. The steadier platform provided by the compensator allows for more precise shot placement, especially in strings of fire. The improved follow-up shot speed also contributes to tighter groups.
Handling and Ergonomics:
The added weight of the compensator slightly alters the balance of the revolver. While some may find this a minor drawback, many shooters report an improved feel, particularly during rapid firing sequences. The overall handling remains manageable and comfortable for most users.
Practical Considerations: Concealed Carry and Everyday Use
While the "Carry Comp" name suggests concealed carry suitability, this is a point of debate among owners. The added length and weight of the compensator make concealed carry more challenging compared to a standard Model 19. Therefore, its practicality for concealed carry largely depends on the individual's body size, clothing choices, and carrying method.
For range use and target practice, however, the Carry Comp excels. The improved accuracy and recoil management make it a joy to shoot, even for extended periods. Its robust construction and reliable action ensure consistent performance, making it a suitable option for both casual and serious shooters.
Strengths and Weaknesses of the Model 19 Carry Comp
Strengths:
- Reduced Recoil: The compensator significantly reduces felt recoil.
- Improved Accuracy: Better recoil control leads to more precise shooting.
- Faster Follow-up Shots: Faster target reacquisition enhances shooting speed.
- Durable Construction: The Model 19 is renowned for its robust build quality.
- Classic Design: The Model 19 retains the timeless appeal of a classic revolver.
Weaknesses:
- Increased Weight and Length: The compensator adds weight and length, impacting concealability.
- Potential for Compensator Damage: Improper cleaning or use can damage the compensator.
- Maintenance: The compensator requires additional cleaning and maintenance.
- Cost: Carry Comp variants usually command a higher price than standard Model 19s.
Conclusion: Is the Model 19 Carry Comp Right for You?
The Model 19 Carry Comp is a fantastic revolver for those prioritizing accuracy and recoil management, particularly during rapid fire drills or target practice. However, its added size and weight make it less ideal for concealed carry. If you value superior shootability and are willing to compromise on concealability, the Model 19 Carry Comp is an excellent choice. If concealed carry is your primary concern, a standard Model 19 or another more compact revolver might be a better fit. Ultimately, the best revolver for you depends on your individual needs and preferences.
