Choosing between the Glock 34 and the Glock 17L often comes down to nuanced preferences in a specific shooting discipline. Both are excellent pistols known for their reliability and accuracy, but subtle differences make one a better fit for certain users than the other. This in-depth comparison will help you determine which Glock best suits your needs.
Key Differences: Size and Weight
The most immediate difference lies in their dimensions. The Glock 34 boasts a longer barrel (5.31 inches vs. 5.38 inches for the 17L), but a shorter slide and overall length than the 17L. This translates to a more manageable and often preferred size for competition shooting, especially in USPSA and IPSC. The 17L's longer slide and barrel contribute to a slightly longer sight radius, potentially enhancing accuracy at longer ranges for target shooting. However, this added length impacts concealability and maneuverability, making the Glock 34 generally favored for carry purposes (though neither is ideal for concealed carry compared to more compact models).
The weight difference is minimal, impacting recoil management only marginally. Both are substantial enough to mitigate felt recoil effectively.
Barrel Length and Accuracy
While the 17L has a marginally longer barrel (a mere 0.07 inches), the practical difference in accuracy is negligible for most shooters. Both pistols are renowned for their inherent accuracy, and the shooter's skill and technique will significantly influence precision more than this minute barrel length variation. The longer sight radius on the 17L might offer a slight advantage at longer distances for experienced shooters, but the difference is not game-changing for the average user.
Ergonomics and Handling
The Glock 34, with its slightly more compact dimensions, tends to offer better ergonomics for some shooters. Its shorter overall length allows for a more comfortable grip and faster target acquisition. However, this is largely subjective. Hand size and individual preferences will determine which pistol feels better in the hand. Both pistols maintain Glock's characteristic, robust, and reliable design.
Intended Use Cases
-
Glock 34: Ideal for competitive shooting (USPSA, IPSC), especially those prioritizing maneuverability and a more compact profile without sacrificing accuracy. Its balanced design also makes it suitable for practical shooting and informal target practice.
-
Glock 17L: Better suited for longer-range target shooting where the slightly extended sight radius might offer a marginal advantage. It is less desirable for concealed carry due to its overall length.
Ammunition Considerations
Both pistols use the same 9mm Luger ammunition, offering a wide variety of choices for practice and competition. The longer barrel of the 17L might theoretically allow for slightly higher muzzle velocities, although the difference would be very slight and barely noticeable in practical shooting scenarios.
Conclusion: The Best Choice Depends on Your Needs
The choice between the Glock 34 and the 17L ultimately depends on your individual needs and shooting discipline. The Glock 34's slightly more compact size and balanced design make it an excellent choice for competition shooters prioritizing maneuverability. The Glock 17L, with its slightly longer barrel and sight radius, offers a marginal advantage for long-range target shooting, but at the cost of concealability. Consider your shooting style, intended use, and personal preferences to make an informed decision. Renting or borrowing each pistol before purchasing would be highly recommended to determine which feels best in your hand and meets your specific shooting requirements.
