Choosing the right firearm for competitive shooting can significantly impact your performance. Two popular choices among Glock enthusiasts are the Glock 17L and the Glock 34. Both are excellent pistols, but they cater to slightly different shooting styles and preferences. This detailed comparison will help you decide which is the better fit for your competitive shooting needs.
Understanding the Key Differences
The core distinction lies in their barrel length and overall size. The Glock 17L boasts a longer 6-inch barrel compared to the Glock 34's 5.3-inch barrel. This seemingly small difference translates to noticeable variations in several key aspects:
Barrel Length and Sight Radius:
-
Glock 17L: The longer barrel provides a longer sight radius, improving accuracy by allowing for finer sight alignment adjustments. This is particularly advantageous in longer-range shooting scenarios common in some competitive disciplines.
-
Glock 34: While its sight radius is shorter than the 17L, it's still significantly longer than most standard-sized Glocks, providing a considerable accuracy advantage over compact models. Its more manageable size might be preferred by shooters with smaller hands or those prioritizing maneuverability.
Recoil Management:
-
Glock 17L: The longer barrel helps mitigate felt recoil, leading to smoother follow-up shots. This is a considerable benefit in rapid-fire stages.
-
Glock 34: While recoil is more noticeable than in the 17L, it remains manageable for most shooters. The slightly lighter weight can contribute to quicker target acquisition between shots.
Overall Size and Weight:
-
Glock 17L: Its length makes it slightly less maneuverable than the 34, potentially impacting performance in close-quarters shooting or dynamic stages.
-
Glock 34: This more compact size and lighter weight contribute to better handling and ease of use, especially in scenarios requiring quick transitions and movement.
Competitive Disciplines and the Ideal Choice
The optimal choice between the Glock 17L and 34 depends heavily on the specific competitive discipline:
USPSA/IPSC:
Both pistols are popular choices in USPSA and IPSC, but the preference often comes down to individual shooter preference. The longer sight radius of the 17L is advantageous in longer-range shooting, while the maneuverability of the 34 might be preferred in tighter stages.
Steel Challenge:
For Steel Challenge, where speed and accuracy at moderate distances are crucial, the Glock 34's balance and maneuverability might offer a slight edge. Its lighter weight contributes to quicker target transitions.
Other Disciplines:
In disciplines with a strong emphasis on longer-range accuracy, the Glock 17L might be favored. However, for close-quarters shooting or scenarios emphasizing speed, the Glock 34 remains a strong contender.
Conclusion: The Verdict is Personal
Ultimately, the "better" pistol depends entirely on your individual shooting style, physical characteristics, and the demands of your chosen competitive shooting discipline. Consider factors like hand size, shooting stance, and personal preference when making your decision. Renting or borrowing both models before committing to a purchase is strongly recommended to determine which one feels most comfortable and performs best for you. The best way to choose is through hands-on experience. Don't rely solely on online reviews—find a range that offers rentals and try them both!
