The 1911 and 2011 platforms represent iconic milestones in pistol design, each boasting a loyal following. While sharing a lineage, key differences distinguish them, particularly concerning magazine capacity and resulting ergonomics. This comprehensive comparison delves into the nuances of double-stack 1911s and 2011s, helping you decide which platform best suits your needs.
Understanding the Lineage: From 1911 to 2011
The legendary Colt 1911, adopted by the US Army in 1911, established a standard for single-stack, .45 ACP pistols. Its design, though refined over the years, remained fundamentally unchanged for decades. The 2011 platform, however, represents a significant evolution, primarily through the adoption of a double-stack magazine. This seemingly simple change has cascading effects on the gun's dimensions, capacity, and overall handling.
Double Stack 1911s: Bridging the Gap
Double-stack 1911s attempt to marry the familiar feel of a 1911 with the increased capacity of a double-stack magazine. This involves significant modifications to the frame, usually widening it to accommodate the larger magazine.
Advantages of Double Stack 1911s:
- Increased Capacity: The most significant advantage is the boosted magazine capacity, typically holding 10-14 rounds compared to the 7-8 rounds of a standard 1911. This offers a considerable tactical advantage in self-defense or competitive shooting.
- Familiarity: For shooters comfortable with the 1911's grip angle and trigger feel, the transition to a double-stack version is relatively smoother than adopting a completely different platform like a 2011.
Disadvantages of Double Stack 1911s:
- Compromised Ergonomics: Widening the grip to accommodate the double-stack magazine can alter the balance and feel, potentially making it less comfortable for smaller hands or those accustomed to the slimmer profile of a single-stack 1911.
- Reliability Concerns: Modifications to the frame and magazine well can sometimes impact reliability, particularly if not executed meticulously. Choosing a reputable manufacturer is crucial.
2011 Pistols: A Modern Interpretation
The 2011 platform represents a more substantial departure from the original 1911 design. While inheriting some key characteristics like the single-action trigger and grip safety, 2011 pistols are engineered from the ground up as double-stack platforms.
Advantages of 2011s:
- Optimized Ergonomics: Designed as double-stack pistols, 2011s generally offer superior ergonomics, with a grip that's often more comfortable and controllable despite the increased capacity.
- Enhanced Reliability: Because they're designed for double-stack operation from the outset, 2011s typically exhibit higher reliability than modified double-stack 1911s.
- Higher Capacity: They typically offer higher magazine capacity than double-stack 1911s, sometimes holding 15 rounds or more.
- Customization Options: The 2011 platform is highly customizable, offering extensive options for upgrades and modifications.
Disadvantages of 2011s:
- Steeper Learning Curve: For those solely familiar with 1911s, the transition to a 2011 might require more adjustment due to the differences in grip and handling characteristics.
- Cost: 2011 pistols are generally more expensive than their 1911 counterparts.
Conclusion: Choosing the Right Platform
The choice between a double-stack 1911 and a 2011 depends heavily on individual preferences and priorities. If you value the familiar feel of a 1911 but need increased capacity, a double-stack 1911 might be a suitable option, provided you choose a reputable manufacturer known for reliability. However, if ergonomics, reliability, and maximum capacity are paramount, the 2011 platform offers a superior, albeit potentially more expensive, solution. Consider your hand size, shooting style, intended use (e.g., competition, self-defense), and budget when making your decision. Thorough research and potentially handling both types of pistols are strongly recommended before purchasing.
