Choosing between a side-by-side (SXS) and an over-under (O/U) double barrel shotgun can feel overwhelming. Both offer the classic elegance and immediate readiness of a double gun, but their subtle differences significantly impact shooting style and performance. This guide dives deep into the nuances of each, helping you decide which configuration best suits your needs.
Understanding the Core Differences: Side-by-Side vs. Over-Under
The most obvious difference lies in the barrel arrangement:
-
Side-by-Side (SXS): The barrels are positioned side-by-side, parallel to each other. This configuration has a long and storied history, deeply rooted in tradition.
-
Over-Under (O/U): One barrel sits directly above the other. This design generally offers a more streamlined profile and often incorporates a slightly higher point of impact.
However, these visual distinctions translate into several key practical differences:
Swing Characteristics and Point of Impact
The barrel arrangement directly influences how the gun swings and where the shot impacts.
-
Side-by-Side Swing: SXS shotguns often exhibit a slightly wider swing due to the wider barrel spacing. Some shooters find this more natural, while others prefer the narrower swing of an O/U. The wider swing can be advantageous in quickly acquiring moving targets at closer ranges.
-
Over-Under Swing: O/U shotguns typically offer a slightly narrower, more centered swing, which many shooters find conducive for longer-range shots and more precise target acquisition. The barrels' vertical alignment can contribute to better barrel alignment.
-
Point of Impact: While both configurations can be regulated to achieve similar points of impact, subtle differences can exist due to the barrel positioning. O/U shotguns often have a slightly higher point of impact, especially at longer ranges. This difference is often negligible at typical hunting distances.
Balance and Handling
The weight distribution and overall balance subtly vary between SXS and O/U shotguns.
-
Side-by-Side Balance: SXS guns, due to their wider barrel spacing, can sometimes feel slightly heavier in the hands. This is particularly noticeable in lighter-weight models.
-
Over-Under Balance: O/U shotguns often present a more balanced feel, especially when carrying them for extended periods. Their more compact design helps with maneuverability.
Cost and Availability
While price varies drastically depending on the manufacturer and materials, generally:
-
Side-by-Side Cost: Entry-level SXS shotguns can sometimes be found at more affordable price points than comparable O/U models. However, high-end SXS shotguns can reach prices comparable to, or exceeding, those of premium O/U shotguns.
-
Over-Under Cost: Generally, top-tier O/U shotguns are often priced higher than comparable SXS models. This is partially due to the manufacturing complexities and the popularity of O/U shotguns in competitive shooting.
Which is Right for You?
The "best" choice depends heavily on your intended use and personal preferences.
-
Side-by-Side Ideal Uses: SXS shotguns excel in close-quarters shooting, particularly in hunting scenarios where quick target acquisition is paramount. Many hunters also appreciate their traditional aesthetic.
-
Over-Under Ideal Uses: O/U shotguns are well-suited for a broader range of applications, including sporting clays, trap shooting, hunting (especially at longer ranges), and upland bird hunting.
Ultimately, the best way to decide is to handle both types of shotguns. Visit a local gun shop and try shooting both SXS and O/U models. Feel the balance, observe the swing, and determine which gun feels more natural and comfortable for you. This hands-on experience will guide you toward the double barrel shotgun that perfectly fits your shooting style and hunting needs.
