Choosing the right framing nailer can significantly impact your productivity and project quality. DeWalt offers a robust selection, and two models frequently top the comparison lists: the DWFP1580 15-Gauge Angled Finish Nailer and the DWFP9310 16-Gauge Straight Finish Nailer. While both are excellent tools, they cater to different needs and applications. This detailed comparison will help you determine which DeWalt nailer best suits your carpentry projects.
Key Differences: Gauge, Functionality, and Application
The most significant difference lies in the gauge and resulting nail size. The DWFP1580 (158) utilizes 15-gauge angled finish nails, while the DWFP9310 (9310) uses 16-gauge straight finish nails. This seemingly small distinction dramatically affects their ideal applications:
-
DWFP1580 (158): This nailer excels at angled applications, making it ideal for trim work, crown molding, baseboards, and other projects requiring precision and a strong hold. The larger 15-gauge nails offer superior holding power, particularly in hardwoods. Its angled design allows for easier nailing in tight spaces and avoids marring the surface of your finished work.
-
DWFP9310 (9310): Designed for straight nailing, the 9310 is perfect for tasks such as furniture assembly, cabinet making, and other applications where a flush finish is crucial. The smaller 16-gauge nails leave smaller holes, requiring less filling and sanding. This nailer is known for its speed and ease of use in less demanding applications.
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown:
| Feature | DWFP1580 (158) | DWFP9310 (9310) |
|---|---|---|
| Gauge | 15-Gauge | 16-Gauge |
| Nail Type | Angled Finish Nails | Straight Finish Nails |
| Ideal Use | Trim work, crown molding, baseboards | Furniture assembly, cabinets, fine woodworking |
| Holding Power | Higher | Lower |
| Hole Size | Larger | Smaller |
| Weight | Typically heavier | Typically lighter |
| Price | Generally higher | Generally lower |
Beyond the Basics: Consider These Factors
While the gauge and nail type are critical, several other factors influence your choice:
-
Budget: The 158 model typically commands a higher price due to its greater power and versatility.
-
Frequency of Use: If you’re a professional using these tools daily, investing in the more robust 158 might be worthwhile. Occasional DIY users may find the 9310 sufficient.
-
Project Requirements: The nature of your projects directly determines the best tool. For delicate woodwork, the 9310’s smaller nails are advantageous. For demanding applications requiring substantial holding power, the 158 is superior.
-
Ergonomics and Ease of Use: Both models are well-regarded for their ease of use and relatively low recoil. Consider trying both if possible before committing to a purchase.
Conclusion: The Right Tool for the Right Job
Ultimately, the best DeWalt nailer – the 158 or the 9310 – depends on your specific needs and project demands. The 158 excels with its power and versatility for heavier-duty applications, while the 9310 provides a more refined finish for detailed work. Carefully evaluate your typical projects and budget to make an informed decision. Investing in the correct tool will save you time, frustration, and ultimately, enhance the quality of your craftsmanship.
