Can You Shoot .357 SIG Out of a .40 S&W? A Definitive No.
The short answer is a resounding no. Attempting to fire a .357 SIG cartridge in a firearm chambered for .40 S&W is extremely dangerous and could have catastrophic consequences. These two cartridges are not interchangeable, despite some superficial similarities. Let's explore why.
Understanding Cartridge Differences: Why They're Incompatible
While both .357 SIG and .40 S&W are popular pistol cartridges, they possess key differences that make them incompatible:
-
Caliber: While the names might suggest a close relationship, the calibers are distinct. .357 SIG refers to its bullet diameter of approximately .355 inches. .40 S&W, on the other hand, has a bullet diameter of approximately .40 inches. This difference alone renders them incompatible.
-
Case Dimensions: The cartridge cases themselves are different sizes and shapes. The .357 SIG case is a bottlenecked design, while the .40 S&W case is straight-walled. Attempting to force a .357 SIG cartridge into a .40 S&W chamber will likely result in a dangerous obstruction and potentially cause damage to the firearm.
-
Pressure: Although both cartridges operate at relatively high pressures, the specific pressure levels are different. The pressure differential could lead to dangerous over-pressurization within the .40 S&W chamber, potentially resulting in a catastrophic malfunction such as a burst barrel, significant damage to the firearm, and serious injury or death to the shooter and those nearby.
Potential Consequences of Mixing Cartridges
Attempting to fire a .357 SIG round in a .40 S&W pistol will almost certainly lead to serious problems:
-
Chamber Obstruction: The smaller, bottlenecked .357 SIG case will likely not fully chamber in a .40 S&W firearm. This obstruction can cause a dangerous situation, potentially leading to a squib load or a complete failure to fire. Cleaning the obstruction might necessitate taking the firearm to a gunsmith.
-
Kaboom: In the unlikely event the round does chamber, the increased pressure from the .357 SIG round firing in the larger .40 S&W chamber may result in a "kaboom" – a catastrophic failure of the firearm. This can cause serious injury, including loss of sight, hearing damage, and potentially death. It also renders the firearm unusable.
-
Damage to the Firearm: Even if a kaboom doesn't occur, the attempt to fire the wrong round will almost certainly cause damage to the firearm. This damage may range from minor to severe, requiring significant and expensive repairs.
Always Double-Check Your Ammunition
This incident highlights the critical importance of always double-checking your ammunition before firing any firearm. This simple yet vital step can prevent serious accidents and ensure the safety of yourself and others. Familiarize yourself with proper firearm safety procedures and handling. If you are unsure about ammunition compatibility, consult a qualified firearms expert or refer to your firearm's owner's manual. Never compromise on safety.
