Choosing between a Beretta 686 and a Browning Citori is a classic dilemma for shotgun enthusiasts. Both are legendary over-and-under shotguns renowned for their quality, reliability, and performance. However, subtle differences in design, feel, and features cater to different shooting styles and preferences. This in-depth comparison will help you determine which gun best suits your needs.
Design and Aesthetics
Both the Beretta 686 and Browning Citori boast elegant designs, reflecting their heritage as high-end sporting shotguns. However, their aesthetics differ subtly.
-
Beretta 686: Known for its sleek, slightly more understated profile. The receiver often features more streamlined lines and less ornamentation than the Citori. The action is renowned for its smooth, reliable operation.
-
Browning Citori: Typically exhibits a more ornate and substantial receiver, often showcasing intricate engraving or other decorative features. This gives it a slightly more luxurious and traditional feel. The Citori is also known for its robust build and classic styling.
Action and Mechanics
Both shotguns employ a box-lock action, a design known for its strength and reliability. However, there are key differences:
-
Beretta 686: Utilizes a monoblock barrel design, which is known for its inherent strength and rigidity. This contributes to consistent shot patterns and reduced recoil. Beretta's action is famously smooth and reliable, requiring minimal maintenance.
-
Browning Citori: Employs a more traditional, split-lug action. While still robust and reliable, this design offers slightly more flexibility in terms of barrel interchangeability, though this is less of a concern for most shooters. The Citori's action is also known for its smooth operation, but some shooters find the Beretta's action slightly smoother.
Handling and Ergonomics
Subjective preferences play a significant role here.
-
Beretta 686: Generally feels slightly lighter and more nimble in the hand, making it preferable for some upland bird hunters and sporting clays shooters who value quick target acquisition and maneuverability.
-
Browning Citori: Often feels slightly heavier and more substantial, which some shooters perceive as contributing to improved stability and reduced felt recoil, particularly beneficial for high-volume shooting or heavier loads.
Features and Options
Both manufacturers offer a wide range of models with varying features:
-
Beretta 686: Available in various configurations, including different barrel lengths, chokes, and stock styles to cater to a wide array of shooting disciplines. Certain models offer features such as adjustable combs for improved fit.
-
Browning Citori: Similarly, boasts a broad selection of models, with options for different gauges, barrel lengths, and stock configurations. The Citori line also includes dedicated sporting clays models and field models, each optimized for its intended purpose.
Price and Value
Both the Beretta 686 and Browning Citori represent a significant investment. Pricing varies based on model, configuration, and condition. Generally, prices are comparable, reflecting the high quality of both shotguns.
Conclusion: Which Shotgun is Right for You?
The choice between a Beretta 686 and a Browning Citori ultimately depends on individual preferences and shooting style. The Beretta 686 might be a better choice for those prioritizing a lighter, nimbler shotgun with a famously smooth action, ideal for upland hunting or fast-paced sporting clays. The Browning Citori, with its more substantial feel and potentially more ornate design, might be better suited for those who prefer a more robust shotgun, perhaps for heavier loads or longer shooting sessions.
The best approach is to handle both shotguns, if possible, and shoot them to determine which feels better and performs more consistently to your shooting style. Consider your intended use—hunting, sporting clays, trap—and prioritize features that align with your specific needs. Both are excellent shotguns built to last a lifetime; the optimal choice is the one that best fits your hand and shooting style.
