The AR-15 platform, a cornerstone of modern firearms, has seen countless iterations and modifications since its inception. While many shooters gravitate towards the sleek, low-profile designs of modern flat-top uppers, the AR-15 with a carry handle retains a certain nostalgic charm and offers a unique shooting experience. This article delves into the pros and cons of this classic configuration, exploring its history, functionality, and place in today's shooting world.
A Blast from the Past: The History of the Carry Handle AR-15
The carry handle upper receiver, integrated with iron sights, was the standard configuration for the original M16 rifle. This design, born from the Vietnam War era, provided a robust and readily available sighting system. The integral carry handle served a dual purpose: acting as both a sighting mechanism and a convenient carrying handle, hence its name. This design dominated the AR-15 landscape for many years before the advent of Picatinny rails and the modularity they offered.
The Allure of the Carry Handle: Pros and Cons
Choosing an AR-15 with a carry handle is a decision with significant implications for both aesthetics and functionality. Let's weigh the advantages and disadvantages:
Advantages:
- Built-in Sighting System: The most immediate benefit is the integrated iron sights. These are generally durable, reliable, and require no additional mounting or zeroing. This is a significant advantage for those seeking a simplified, ready-to-shoot setup.
- Robust Construction: Carry handle uppers are often considered more robust due to the added material in the upper receiver. This added strength can be beneficial in harsh conditions.
- No Rail Interference: With the sights built into the upper receiver, there's no concern about interfering with optics or accessories mounted on a Picatinny rail. This streamlined design can lead to a smoother profile for certain applications.
- Nostalgia and Classic Appeal: For many shooters, the carry handle represents a piece of firearms history. The retro aesthetic is appealing to collectors and those who appreciate classic designs.
Disadvantages:
- Limited Mounting Options: The lack of a Picatinny rail on top limits the versatility in mounting optics or other accessories. This restricts the user to iron sights unless they modify the receiver.
- Higher Sightline: The carry handle's elevated sightline can make shooting from lower positions more challenging, especially compared to a low-profile flat-top upper.
- Weight: The integrated carry handle adds some weight to the overall firearm. While this isn't significant, it's a factor to consider, particularly for extended use.
- Potentially Obstructed Optics: While not a major issue for all users, the carry handle can sometimes obstruct the view when using certain magnifiers or scopes.
Modern Applications of the Carry Handle AR-15
Despite the rise of flat-top uppers, the carry handle AR-15 still holds a place in the shooting world. Some common applications include:
- Budget-Friendly Option: Carry handle rifles can sometimes be found at more affordable price points than their flat-top counterparts.
- Collectors' Items: These rifles are sought after by collectors interested in preserving a piece of firearms history.
- Dedicated Iron Sight Shooters: For shooters who prefer iron sights and appreciate their simplicity and reliability, the carry handle offers a practical solution.
- Retro-Style Builds: Many shooters build custom AR-15s incorporating a carry handle for a classic, nostalgic look.
Conclusion
The AR-15 with a carry handle is more than just a relic of the past. It offers a unique combination of robust construction, readily available iron sights, and a distinctive aesthetic. While it might not be the most versatile or modern option available, it continues to appeal to a segment of shooters who value reliability, simplicity, and a touch of history in their firearms. The decision to choose a carry handle AR-15 ultimately depends on individual preferences and intended applications. Understanding the pros and cons outlined above will help you decide if this classic configuration is the right choice for you.
