The AR-15 platform's modularity allows for a wide range of configurations, and the carry handle upper receiver represents a classic and often overlooked option. While less common than flattop uppers, carry handle uppers offer distinct advantages and disadvantages that shooters should consider before purchasing. This guide will delve into the details, exploring their history, benefits, drawbacks, and ultimately helping you decide if a carry handle upper is the right choice for your AR-15 build.
A Blast from the Past: The History of the Carry Handle Upper
The carry handle upper receiver was the original design for the AR-15, integrating the rear sight directly into the upper receiver. This design, born from the M16's military origins, offered a robust and integrated sighting system. The fixed carry handle provided a reliable, durable aiming solution, particularly crucial in harsh conditions. As the AR-15 evolved for civilian use, the flattop upper receiver gained popularity, offering greater versatility in optics mounting. However, the carry handle upper retains a loyal following among enthusiasts and practical shooters.
Advantages of the AR-15 Carry Handle Upper
Several key advantages make the carry handle upper receiver a compelling option for certain applications:
Integrated Sighting System:
- Durability: The integral rear sight is known for its ruggedness and reliability, built to withstand considerable abuse.
- Simplicity: No separate rear sight to mount or lose—everything is built-in.
- Co-Witnessing: While not as common with modern optics, some users appreciate the co-witnessing capabilities with certain low-profile red dot sights.
Weight Distribution:
- Balanced Feel: The weight of the carry handle contributes to a more balanced feel, especially when compared to a front-heavy setup with a heavy optic mounted on a flattop upper.
Nostalgia and Aestetics:
- Classic Look: Many shooters appreciate the classic, retro aesthetic of the carry handle upper, harkening back to the original AR-15 design.
Disadvantages of the AR-15 Carry Handle Upper
Despite its advantages, the carry handle upper also presents some limitations:
Limited Optic Mounting Options:
- No Picatinny Rail: The lack of a Picatinny rail on top limits the types of optics that can be easily mounted. While some adapters exist, they are not always ideal.
Height Over Bore:
- Higher Sight Picture: The higher sight picture compared to a low-profile optic mounted on a flattop can make for a less comfortable cheek weld, especially for shooters with shorter necks.
Weight:
- Heavier than Flattop Uppers: While the weight distribution is beneficial for some, the overall weight of the carry handle upper is generally higher than a comparable flattop upper receiver.
Choosing the Right Upper: Carry Handle vs. Flattop
The choice between a carry handle and a flattop upper receiver depends largely on individual needs and preferences.
-
Flattop uppers offer unparalleled versatility in optics mounting and customization. They are ideal for shooters who want to use a wide variety of sights and accessories.
-
Carry handle uppers are best suited for those who prioritize a robust, integrated sighting system, prefer a more balanced feel, and appreciate the classic design. They are a practical and reliable option for users who may not need the extreme versatility of a flattop.
Conclusion: A Classic with Modern Considerations
The AR-15 carry handle upper receiver is more than just a piece of history; it's a viable option for many shooters. Understanding its advantages and disadvantages will help you determine if this classic design is the right fit for your next AR-15 build. Weigh the benefits of its integrated sighting system and balanced feel against the limitations of its optic mounting options and higher sight picture. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs and shooting style.
