The AR-15 platform, renowned for its adaptability and modularity, boasts a rich history. Among its many variations, the carry handle upper receiver stands out, offering a distinct aesthetic and a unique shooting experience. While not as prevalent as the more modern flattop designs, the carry handle AR-15 retains a dedicated following among shooters who appreciate its retro charm and certain functional advantages. This article delves into the specifics of AR-15 rifles equipped with carry handles, exploring their history, advantages, disadvantages, and considerations for prospective buyers.
A Blast from the Past: The History of the Carry Handle AR-15
The carry handle upper receiver was the original design incorporated into the M16 rifle, and subsequently, the AR-15. Its integrated rear sight, built directly into the upper receiver, provided a robust and reliable sighting system. This design was a key feature of early AR-15 variants and saw extensive service in various military conflicts. The carry handle's durability and simplicity made it a practical choice in challenging environments. However, the rise of modularity and the desire for greater optic versatility eventually led to the dominance of the flattop upper receiver.
Advantages of an AR-15 with Carry Handle
Despite its less prevalent status, the carry handle AR-15 still offers several advantages:
Built-in Sight System:
- Reliability: The integrated rear sight is known for its robust construction and resistance to damage, even under harsh conditions. It’s a simple, reliable system with minimal moving parts.
- Durability: The rear sight is inherently protected by its position on the upper receiver, reducing the risk of damage compared to externally mounted sights.
Weight Distribution:
- Balanced Feel: The carry handle's weight contributes to a more balanced feel during shooting, especially for those accustomed to its weight distribution. This can improve control and accuracy.
Unique Aesthetic:
- Retro Appeal: The classic look of a carry handle AR-15 appeals to many shooters who appreciate its vintage aesthetic and connection to the platform’s history.
Disadvantages of an AR-15 with Carry Handle
While the carry handle AR-15 offers several advantages, it also presents certain drawbacks:
Limited Optic Options:
- No Picatinny Rail: The lack of a Picatinny rail on top of the upper receiver limits the options for mounting modern optics like red dot sights, holographic sights, or magnified scopes. While some carry handle uppers incorporate a Picatinny rail on the side, it's less versatile than a full-length top rail.
- Co-witnessing Challenges: If a low-profile optic is desired, the use of a lower 1/3 co-witness setup may not always be achievable, thus, limiting the adaptability of the weapon system.
Height of the Sight System:
- Eye Relief: The higher sight plane of the carry handle can impact eye relief, making it less comfortable for some shooters.
Bulkier Design:
- Less Compact: The integrated carry handle contributes to a slightly bulkier and less compact profile compared to flattop designs.
Modern Carry Handle Options and Considerations
While traditional carry handle uppers maintain a distinct retro style, some modern manufacturers offer updated versions. Some incorporate side rails for mounting accessories, while others retain the classic design for purists. It's crucial to consider the specific features and capabilities of a carry handle upper receiver before purchasing one.
Conclusion: Choosing the Right AR-15
The decision of whether to choose an AR-15 with a carry handle or a flattop upper receiver depends entirely on individual preferences and intended use. The carry handle offers a classic aesthetic, robust built-in sights, and a unique shooting feel. However, the limited optic versatility and higher sight plane might outweigh these benefits for some shooters. For those seeking maximum adaptability and the ability to mount a wide range of optics, a flattop upper receiver is generally preferred. Ultimately, careful consideration of these factors will lead to the selection of the most suitable AR-15 platform for your needs.
