Choosing the right shotgun can be a daunting task, especially when comparing legendary models like the Remington 1100 and 1187. Both are renowned for their reliability and performance, but understanding their key differences is crucial for making an informed decision. This comprehensive comparison will delve into the features, strengths, and weaknesses of each, helping you determine which shotgun best suits your needs.
Design and Operation: Key Differences
The Remington 1100 and 1187, while sharing a lineage, boast distinct operational mechanisms. This fundamental difference significantly impacts their feel, maintenance, and overall performance.
Remington 1100: The Long-Stroke Gas System
The 1100 operates on a long-recoil, gas-operated system. This means the entire bolt assembly moves rearward with the force of the recoiling gases. This system, while contributing to the gun's smooth operation and relatively low recoil, is slightly more complex mechanically than the 1187's system. Cleaning requires slightly more attention to detail.
Remington 1187: The Short-Stroke Gas System
The 1187 utilizes a short-recoil, gas-operated system. Only a portion of the bolt assembly moves rearward, simplifying the mechanism and making it potentially more durable and less prone to malfunctions caused by debris. This system generally requires less cleaning and maintenance compared to the 1100.
Reliability and Durability: A Close Contest
Both the 1100 and 1187 boast reputations for exceptional reliability. However, subtle differences exist.
Remington 1100: A Proven Track Record
The 1100's long history speaks volumes about its dependability. Millions have been produced and used in various conditions, solidifying its reputation as a workhorse. Its long-stroke operation, while potentially requiring more maintenance, has proven highly effective over decades.
Remington 1187: Modern Reliability
The 1187, being a later design, incorporated improvements in materials and manufacturing techniques. Its shorter-stroke mechanism simplifies the internal workings, often leading to reduced downtime and easier troubleshooting.
Recoil and Handling: Subjective Preferences
Recoil perception is subjective, influenced by factors like shooter size and the type of ammunition used. However, general observations suggest the following:
Remington 1100: Smoother Recoil (Generally)
The 1100's long-recoil system tends to distribute recoil energy more smoothly, often resulting in a perceived softer recoil than the 1187.
Remington 1187: Snappier Recoil (Generally)
The 1187's short-recoil system can deliver a more noticeable recoil impulse, although this is still manageable for most shooters. This snappier recoil might be preferred by some for faster follow-up shots.
Maintenance and Cleaning: Practical Considerations
Both shotguns require regular cleaning, but the methods and complexity differ.
Remington 1100: More Complex Cleaning
The 1100's long-stroke gas system involves more components during disassembly for cleaning. This requires a slightly more thorough cleaning process and a deeper understanding of the firearm’s mechanism.
Remington 1187: Easier Cleaning
The 1187's simplified short-stroke mechanism makes cleaning easier and faster. Fewer parts means less time spent on maintenance.
Choosing the Right Shotgun: Your Specific Needs
Ultimately, the best shotgun depends on your individual needs and shooting style. Consider the following:
- Budget: Used 1100s can often be found at attractive prices, while 1187s might be slightly more expensive depending on condition and availability.
- Maintenance preference: If you prefer simpler maintenance, the 1187 might be a better choice.
- Recoil sensitivity: If recoil is a significant concern, the 1100’s smoother recoil might be more comfortable.
- Intended use: Both are versatile, but the choice might be guided by the type of shooting (e.g., hunting, sporting clays, trap).
Both the Remington 1100 and 1187 are excellent shotguns with a rich history. Careful consideration of the points highlighted above will help you make a well-informed decision and select the perfect firearm for your shooting adventures.
